financetom
Economy
financetom
/
Economy
/
Analysis-Painful policy choices loom after China's 'monumental' consumer stimulus plan
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Analysis-Painful policy choices loom after China's 'monumental' consumer stimulus plan
Sep 29, 2024 11:58 PM

BEIJING/HONG KONG (Reuters) - China's stimulus plans to fill consumer pockets to meet its 2024 growth target breaks away from a decades-old policy playbook, but making household demand a sustainable driver of development instead of investment is a long path paved with tough choices.

Reuters reported last week that Beijing plans to issue sovereign bonds worth about 2 trillion yuan ($284 billion) this year, in part to subsidise consumer goods purchases and child support, effectively transferring funds to households.

That marks a shift towards stimulating consumption that many economists have called on Beijing to pursue for more than a decade, warning that China may otherwise grind towards a prolonged period of low growth as seen in Japan in the 1990s.

"It's monumental - a landmark event that the policy mindset has reversed," said Tianchen Xu, an economist at the Economist Intelligence Unit.

The tension lies in a growth model from the 1980s that many economists say has relied too heavily on investment in property, infrastructure and industry at the expense of consumers.

Economists say this model has created overcapacity in infrastructure and manufacturing and led to a staggering and unsustainable debt surge since the global financial crisis as investment returns dwindled.

While this year's consumer-focused efforts are likely to be enough to bring China's 2024 growth back to about 5% after below-forecast data in the past several months cast doubts over that target, they hardly change the long-term outlook.

China's household spending is less than 40% of annual economic output, some 20 percentage points below the global average. Investment, by comparison, is 20 points above.

Closing that gap cannot happen overnight. It took Japan 17 years to raise the consumption share of its economic output by 10 percentage points from its bottom in 1991, says Michael Pettis, senior fellow at Carnegie China.

The latest fiscal effort "isn't really part of a real structural rebalancing", Pettis said.

"Rebalancing will require a shift in the economic model that will reverse decades of explicit and implicit transfers in which households have subsidised investment and production."

STRUCTURAL ISSUES

The current socioeconomic policy architecture is built to prop up investment, not consumption.

For decades, households have been squeezed by low deposit rates, weak labour rights and farmer land rights contributing to low incomes, and a frail social safety net.

The tax system incentivises high investment and low wages.

China taxes capital gains at 20%, lower than the 30% in India and 37% in the United States. China's upper personal income tax band is among the world's steepest, at 45%.

Businesses, especially in strategic industries, get frequent tax exemptions and other incentives from both central and local governments. Supporting strategic sectors, or what Beijing calls "new productive forces" such as electric vehicles, green energy or robotics, are part of efforts of technological advancement that China sees as vital for national security.

Re-imagining the policy playbook to empower consumers would require a major coordinated effort from authorities over many years, analysts say.

Not to mention the risks.

"The 'correct' way to rebalance the economy towards consumption would be to stop subsidizing manufacturing companies with the money of households," says Juan Orts, China economist at Fathom Consulting.

"What that would result in is a shrinking size of the manufacturing sector, leading to a sharp drop in investment and therefore a recession," added Orts.

Orts, however, predicts that China is more likely to opt for a protracted period of rebalancing, leading to "Japanification".

To fund this year's last-ditch fiscal efforts, Beijing is expected to issue more debt, rather than alter the mechanisms of income distribution between business, government and households.

"The central government can probably fund fiscal transfers for a few years more," Carnegie China's Pettis said.

"But if Beijing doesn't transform the growth model, the imbalances will continue to build, in which case China risks facing the same problem in the future as it does now, only without a clean central-government balance sheet to help it manage potential disruptions."

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
US Dollar Falls Early Monday, Eyes on Consumer Price Index Data During Fed 'Quiet Period'
US Dollar Falls Early Monday, Eyes on Consumer Price Index Data During Fed 'Quiet Period'
Dec 9, 2024
07:55 AM EST, 12/09/2024 (MT Newswires) -- The US dollar fell against its major trading partners early Monday, except for a gain versus the yen, as markets now focus on data releases, particularly inflation data, in the absence of comments from Federal Reserve officials who are in their 'quiet period' ahead of the Dec. 17-18 Federal Open Market Committee meeting....
US consumers expect higher inflation and better economy, New York Fed says
US consumers expect higher inflation and better economy, New York Fed says
Dec 9, 2024
(Reuters) - U.S. consumers were bracing last month for higher levels of inflation in coming years even as they marked up expectations that their personal financial situations would improve markedly, the New York Federal Reserve reported on Monday. Respondents to the regional Fed bank's survey of consumer expectations in November see inflation a year from now at 3%, versus the...
US Listed Chinese Stocks Jump On China's Stimulus Measures, Looser Monetary Policy Assurances
US Listed Chinese Stocks Jump On China's Stimulus Measures, Looser Monetary Policy Assurances
Dec 9, 2024
On Monday, U.S.-listed Chinese stocks like Alibaba Group Holding ( BABA ). , JD.com, Inc. ( JD ) , Baidu, Inc. , NIO Inc. , Li Auto Inc. , and XPeng Inc.  maintained their upward trajectory ahead of a key policy meeting this week. China reportedly plans to host its annual economic planning meeting, at which it will discuss its financial goals and additional stimulus measures. On Monday, President Xi Jinping led...
Factbox-Brokerages still expect 25-bps US rate cut in December
Factbox-Brokerages still expect 25-bps US rate cut in December
Dec 9, 2024
(Reuters) - Citigroup has lowered its expectations for an interest-rate cut at the U.S. Federal Reserve's December meeting, joining peers in predicting a 25-basis-point reduction, following robust nonfarm payrolls data. Brokerages including Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs reiterated their expectation of a 25-basis-point cut after the jobs data. Data showed nonfarm payrolls increased by 227,000 jobs last month after rising...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved