financetom
Economy
financetom
/
Economy
/
Election freebies affect debt levels of states, capital expenditure is likely to suffer: Expert
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Election freebies affect debt levels of states, capital expenditure is likely to suffer: Expert
May 19, 2023 12:41 PM

The Karnataka election confirms that three kinds of poll promises are going to flow freely in the coming state elections — and even the national election next year — 1) A basic income for every household, call it for women or call it Kisan Samman Nidhi, 2) Free electricity, and 3) Free foodgrain..

But can the state finances absorb such huge expenses? Last year, state fiscal deficits only stood at 2.6 percent of GDP, and most states didn't reach the 3 percent limit allowed to them, but this doesn't take into account unpaid dues to power discoms.

Another surprising facet we need to remember is, when it comes to debt and deficit, the centre appears to be the bigger culprit. Here's some data from the government's status paper on debt. It shows that the central government's accumulated debt is 59.2 percent of GDP as of FY21, while the aggregate of all state government debt is less than half that at 28.6 percent of GDP.

Again nearly 42 percent of the centre's revenue receipts goes to pay interest; where as interest accounts for only 14 percent of state government's revenue receipts.

So clearly, the central government, more than states, is guilty of living or promising beyond its means. Does it get far worse? What can be the consequences for the financial sector and the economy? And how can it be arrested?

Speaking to CNBC-TV18, Ajay Narayan Jha, former member of 15th Finance Commission, said that debt levels of states are being stretched and capital expenditure is likely to suffer.

"There is a fiscal cap on the borrowing that states undertake and that will limit the extent of debt which they can take. However what we had observed is that the debt levels of even a state like Karnataka which has been the flagbearer of fiscal responsibility over the last two decades or so, has been stretched and their interest liabilities have gone up. What is worrying at a state level is that if this type of subsidies or freebies or whatever name you give to them, becomes a template as we go into the future, then the capital expenditure which the states undertake is likely to suffer. So that will have long term consequences," Jha said.

Also Read: Karnataka election: BJP, Congress promise expensive freebies — Here's how much it will cost

According to Jha another cause for concern is the high cost of committed expenditure of states.

"Another cause for concern is the high cost of committed expenditure of states. Out of 28 states, only 11 have committed expenditure to own revenue receipts ratio of less than 100. Out of the 11, only three are below 50 — Karnataka, Maharashtra, and Goa. So as we go forward, this type of indulgence of fiscal adventurism is going to have consequences which we witnessed in late 90s when the fiscal position of the states had become very bad," Jha said.

Watch video for entire conversation.

First Published:May 19, 2023 9:41 PM IST

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
US Dollar Rises Early Wednesday Ahead of FOMC Meeting Statement, Powell
US Dollar Rises Early Wednesday Ahead of FOMC Meeting Statement, Powell
Mar 20, 2024
07:44 AM EDT, 03/20/2024 (MT Newswires) -- The US dollar rose against its major trading partners early Wednesday as markets anticipate the Federal Open Market Committee will leave the target range for the federal funds rate at 5.25% to 5.50% in its statement due for release at 2:00 pm ET, focusing attention on any changes in the statement, the updated...
Southwest Airlines reaches tentative agreement with flight attendants' union
Southwest Airlines reaches tentative agreement with flight attendants' union
Mar 20, 2024
(Reuters) - Southwest Airlines ( LUV ) said on Wednesday it has reached a tentative agreement, including for better wages, with its flight attendants' union in a new contract covering nearly 20,000 cabin crew members. The airline's flight attendants had been demanding higher pay and better work rules. The previous contract came up for renewal in 2018. In the past...
Fed's rate-cut confidence likely shaken but not yet broken by inflation
Fed's rate-cut confidence likely shaken but not yet broken by inflation
Mar 20, 2024
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Federal Reserve officials left their policy meeting in late January in search of greater confidence that inflation was on a sustainable downward path, a notably squishy standard they set for determining when the U.S. central bank might start cutting interest rates. Instead, they've have been buffeted by services prices roaring upward, job growth that continues to surprise...
Policy uncertainty drives investors into US medium-term bond funds
Policy uncertainty drives investors into US medium-term bond funds
Mar 20, 2024
By Patturaja Murugaboopathy (Reuters) - Investors are flocking to U.S. medium-term government bond funds and helping push their assets to record highs, as uncertainty about the Federal Reserve's policy path prompts them to seek the sweet spot between income and protection. According to Morningstar Direct data, U.S. medium-term government bond funds, which include Treasuries and debt issued by government-linked agencies,...
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved