financetom
Economy
financetom
/
Economy
/
How Harris' and Trump's tax and spending plans affect US debt
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
How Harris' and Trump's tax and spending plans affect US debt
Sep 11, 2024 12:15 AM

WASHINGTON, Sept 10 (Reuters) - Vice President Kamala

Harris and Republican opponent Donald Trump have floated new tax

breaks and spending plans, as they try to win votes by

persuading Americans their ideas will do more to ease their

financial burdens.

Budget forecasters are struggling to keep up with the latest

tweaks, and new ideas may be voiced in Tuesday's Harris-Trump

debate, but so far all estimates show Trump's agenda piling up

much more new federal debt.

Trump has said he plans to extend all tax cuts he pushed

through Congress in 2017, exempt Social Security and tip income

from taxes, and further cut corporate income taxes.

These changes would likely add $3.6 trillion to $6.6

trillion to primary U.S. deficits over 10 years, according to

published individual and comprehensive estimates from four

budget forecasters reviewed by Reuters: the Penn-Wharton Budget

Model, the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB),

the Tax Foundation and Oxford Economics.

Harris' plans, which include expanding the Child Tax Credit,

a $6,000 bonus tax credit for newborns, a $25,000 first-time

homebuyer tax credit, and no taxes on tips, could reduce

deficits by as much as $400 billion or add up to $1.4 trillion

to deficits over a decade, the same forecasters calculated.

The estimates are based on static budget scoring, and are

compared against the Congressional Budget Office's current-law

"baseline," which already assumes a massive, $22 trillion

increase in debt through 2034.

ROLLING ANALYSIS

The forecasts vary considerably depending on which ideas

mentioned on the campaign trail are included.

Estimates of Harris' recently rolled-out tax deduction of up

to $50,000 for business startup costs, and a lower top capital

gains tax than the one proposed by President Joe Biden are

largely not included.

The forecasts include Trump's proposal to lower the

corporate income tax to 15% from 21% but not his latest comments

that this rate would be reserved only for companies that produce

their goods in the U.S.

"The campaign talking points are moving faster than the

budget models," said Shai Akabas, economic policy director for

the Bipartisan Policy Center. "I think we're largely seeing what

we've come to expect in recent years, which is that candidates

are going to put their popular policy priorities ahead of fiscal

responsibility on both sides."

Congress must approve tax and spending legislation, making

it difficult for the winner of the Nov. 5 election to achieve

their priorities without sweeping majorities in both the Senate

and the House of Representatives.

2025 TAX CLIFF

The major differentiator between Trump and Harris is how

they address the 2025 expiration of individual tax cuts passed

by Republicans during Trump's presidency in 2017. Without action

by Congress, these rates would snap back to their previous,

higher levels.

Trump has pledged to permanently extend all of the expiring

tax cuts, including for the wealthiest Americans, which tax and

budget experts estimate would reduce revenues over a decade by

about $3.3 trillion to $4 trillion.

Harris would extend the 2017 tax cuts for only those earning

under $400,000, keeping a Biden pledge, but this would add up to

$2.5 trillion to a spending agenda already estimated at $2

trillion over a decade.

Harris has quietly endorsed the nearly $5 trillion in tax

hikes in Biden's fiscal 2025 budget request, including taxing

unrealized gains from fortunes over $100 billion and raising the

corporate tax rate to 28%

This has caused consternation on Wall Street but would

substantially offset the cost of her spending plans.

"I think the conclusion that Trump's approach to taxes is

more debt-fueled is correct," said Steve Rosenthal, a senior

fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. "I say that

because Harris at least has some pretty well-developed revenue

raisers."

Trump has not offered any conventional tax increases to

offset his extended tax cuts. Other breaks, including exempting

Social Security income, would reduce revenue by $1.6 trillion,

CRFB and the Tax Foundation estimate.

The conservative-leaning Tax Foundation called the move

"unsound and fiscally irresponsible," weakening Social Security

and Medicare.

Trump has said his tax cuts would be paid for with

"trillions of dollars" generated by stronger economic growth,

new import tariffs, ending Biden's clean energy subsidies and a

new government efficiency commission headed by billionaire

entrepreneur and Tesla CEO Elon Musk.

The Tax Policy Center has estimated that Trump's proposed

10% global tariff and 60% tariff on Chinese imports could raise

up to $3.8 trillion over a decade but would reduce other

revenues due to its economic effects, including imposing a de

facto tax on households.

The Tax Foundation was the only model reviewed that included

a tariff estimate as an offset -- $2.6 trillion -- but even

then, it estimated that Trump's plans would boost deficits by

nearly $4 trillion over a decade.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Strong US jobs data complicates any Warsh push for lower rates
Strong US jobs data complicates any Warsh push for lower rates
May 8, 2026
NEW YORK, May 8 (Reuters) - Strong U.S. hiring data in April dealt prospective Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh's hopes of cutting interest rates a setback on Friday, giving officials greater latitude to use monetary policy to tackle increasingly high inflation. The U.S. economy added 115,000 new jobs in April, exceeding analysts' forecasts, following an upwardly revised job gain of...
April Nonfarm Payrolls Top Views; Fed Seen Holding Rates Again
April Nonfarm Payrolls Top Views; Fed Seen Holding Rates Again
May 8, 2026
11:04 AM EDT, 05/08/2026 (MT Newswires) -- The US economy added more jobs than projected in April, allaying concerns about a slowdown in the labor market and likely allowing the Federal Reserve to stick to its current policy stance. Total nonfarm payrolls rose by 115,000 last month, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said Friday, well above the 65,000 increase expected...
Fed's Goolsbee tells CNBC that job market is holding in
Fed's Goolsbee tells CNBC that job market is holding in
May 8, 2026
May 8 (Reuters) - Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago President Austan Goolsbee said on Friday that April hiring data shows more stability in the employment sector amid worrisome developments on the inflation front. The job market has been stable without being good and I still think there's not a lot of evidence that the job market is falling apart, the...
April jobs report shows continued strength
April jobs report shows continued strength
May 8, 2026
NEW YORK, May 8 (Reuters) - U.S. employment increased more than expected in April while the unemployment rate held steady at 4.3%, pointing to labor market resilience and reinforcing expectations that the Federal Reserve would leave interest rates unchanged for some time. Nonfarm payrolls increased by 115,000 jobs last month after an upwardly revised 185,000 advance in March, the Labor...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved