financetom
Economy
financetom
/
Economy
/
USDA redaction of trade analysis causes concern about report integrity
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
USDA redaction of trade analysis causes concern about report integrity
Jun 9, 2025 3:29 AM

CHICAGO/WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Analysts voiced concerns this week about the integrity of U.S. Department of Agriculture reports after the agency delayed a report and excluded findings that point to tariffs as a reason for a forecasted increase in the agricultural trade deficit, according to Reuters interviews with four analysts.

The administration of President Donald Trump has pledged to shrink the farm trade deficit and has said tariffs will strengthen the farm economy, but farm groups have been critical of the approach. 

The agency's delay of a quarterly agricultural trade report and exclusion of its typical explanatory text were concerning because the moves raised questions about the objectivity of the data, two analysts said.

"The trade is uneasy about USDA statistics now," said Charlie Sernatinger, head of grains with Marex, a brokerage and financial services company.     

A USDA spokesperson said the report was delayed by an internal review. 

"The report was hung up in internal clearance process and was not finalized in time for its typical deadline. Given this report is not statutory as with many other reports USDA does, the department is undergoing a review of all of its non-statutory reports, including this one, to determine next steps," the spokesperson said.

The quarterly trade outlook report jointly published by the USDA's Economic Research Service and Foreign Agricultural Service was scheduled to be released on May 29. Shortly before it was set to publish, its authors were told to stop its release, according to a source familiar with the situation. 

The authors were then questioned by leaders at the ERS, FAS and USDA Office of the Chief Economist about the report's attribution of the growing agriculture trade deficit to tariffs and sentiments like "Buy Canadian" that have reduced demand for U.S. goods, the source said. In the delayed report released on Monday, the USDA raised its forecast of the U.S. agriculture trade deficit for fiscal-year 2025 to $49.5 billion, from the $49 billion it previously forecast in February.

The version of the report published on Monday contains correct and unaltered data, the source said, but excludes explanatory text typically contained in the forecasts. 

The report delay and redaction were first reported by Politico.

Such trade reports would typically be reviewed by communications and policy staff, but the removal of the explanatory text was highly unusual, according to a second source familiar with the report publication process.

Two other analysts said they were confident in the USDA data for now, but expressed concern about how Trump's disruption of the federal government could affect future reports. 

"Departures of key personnel limit the ability of agencies to collect and analyze information," said Patrick Westhoff, director of the Food and Agricultural Policy Research Institute at the University of Missouri. 

The USDA has lost about 27% of ERS employees and 14% of FAS employees to terminations or voluntary incentives to leave the agency as the Trump administration works to reduce the size and cost of the federal government, according to Reuters reporting.

The U.S. had an agricultural trade surplus for decades but in recent years, imports of high-value goods like alcohol, fruits and vegetables have driven a growing deficit, according to USDA data.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Federal Reserve Watch for May 16: Mester Says Policy Rate Should Remain Steady Until More Confidence on Inflation Progress
Federal Reserve Watch for May 16: Mester Says Policy Rate Should Remain Steady Until More Confidence on Inflation Progress
May 16, 2024
02:23 PM EDT, 05/16/2024 (MT Newswires) -- Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester (voter) said the current level of monetary policy is sufficient to address how the economy evolves and it would be 'prudent' to leave policy there until the Federal Open Market Committee gains greater confidence in the progress on inflation. Recent comments of note: (May 15) New York Fed...
April Industrial Production Stagnates Amid Surprise Drop in Manufacturing Output
April Industrial Production Stagnates Amid Surprise Drop in Manufacturing Output
May 16, 2024
03:17 PM EDT, 05/16/2024 (MT Newswires) -- US industrial production was flat in April versus market expectations for a gain as manufacturing output posted a surprise decline, according to Federal Reserve data published Thursday. Industrial output was unchanged last month following a downwardly revised 0.1% increase in March, the Fed said. The consensus was for a 0.1% rise in a...
Fed remains cautious on cuts even as data improves
Fed remains cautious on cuts even as data improves
May 16, 2024
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Data this week offered the U.S. Federal Reserve good news on two fronts but policymakers haven't openly shifted views yet about the timing of rate cuts investors are convinced will start this year. Comments from Fed officials including the vice chair of the rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee, New York Fed President John Williams, acknowledged the positive...
Mid-Atlantic Manufacturing Activity Falls More Than Expected as Demand Wanes
Mid-Atlantic Manufacturing Activity Falls More Than Expected as Demand Wanes
May 16, 2024
03:50 PM EDT, 05/16/2024 (MT Newswires) -- Manufacturing activity in the Mid-Atlantic region declined more than expected this month as orders and shipments fell into negative territory, the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia said Thursday. The Manufacturing Business Outlook Survey's headline gauge for business activity dropped to 4.5 in May from 15.5 in April, mostly undoing the index's increase from...
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved