financetom
Personal Finance
financetom
/
Personal Finance
/
The S&P 500 is whipsawing -- and taking brokerage stocks along for the ride
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
The S&P 500 is whipsawing -- and taking brokerage stocks along for the ride
Mar 14, 2025 5:34 PM

When your revenue relies on generating transaction fees, your customers' moods have an outsize impact on your business prospects. While you might think that this dour environment is good for brokerage firms -- with traders frantically placing more orders, even if they're selling -- the opposite is actually true.

Brokerage firms feeling the heat

Some of the hardest-hit stocks in the recent market downdraft have been those of brokerages like Robinhood (HOOD) and Interactive Brokers ( IBKR ) . Others -- like Charles Schwab ( SCHW ) -- have also fallen, but not as dramatically. You can probably guess by reputation alone which of these companies are reliant on customers who generate trading revenue.

Millennials and Gen Zers are Robinhood's people. And though the broker has toned down the gamification of investing in recent years (no more confetti!), it's still a draw for short-term, glued-to-their phones traders. True to the brand, the company has been the most volatile of this trio.

On Monday, Robinhood's share price plummeted more than 20 percent. Why the big whammy? On March 7, the broker got slapped with a $26 million fine by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) for multiple violations, some of which go back years. It was also ordered to pay $3.75 million in restitution to customers whose trades were executed at an inferior price (due to a practice called "collaring," or converting market orders to limit orders).

Need an advisor?

Need expert guidance when it comes to managing your investments or planning for retirement?

Bankrate's AdvisorMatch can connect you to a CFP(R) professional to help you achieve your financial goals.

Robinhood also relies heavily on crypto transaction revenue. Although President Trump's announcement of a strategic cryptocurrency reserve provided a slight bump to falling Bitcoin and Ethereum prices, plunging crypto prices may be impacting the highly lucrative trading volume that Robinhood relies on.

If Robinhood is the go-to platform for budding stock jocks, Interactive Brokers ( IBKR ) is the sophisticated uncle who actively manages his portfolio with the latest and greatest advanced trading tools. Still, that didn't spare the broker from a bad case of the Mondays.

Like Robinhood, Interactive Brokers ( IBKR ) relies heavily on transaction fees from traders. The stock's 16 percent single-day drop was its largest price decline in years on top of a miserable February.

Despite the volatility -- or, rather, because of the recent beat-down that has cut its share price by nearly a third -- some analysts are optimistic about Interactive Brokers' ( IBKR ) future prospects, especially as it expands its reach beyond the U.S. market to attract a global clientele of traders. Still, the company's reliance on trading volume makes it extremely susceptible to investor whims.

Finally, the granddaddy of brokers, Charles Schwab ( SCHW ), took Monday's blow to the chin like a champ. Its share price declined a mere 3 percent.

Compared to Robinhood and Interactive Brokers ( IBKR ), Schwab's exposure to customer jitters isn't as pronounced. In addition to its brokerage business, the company offers a robo-advisory portfolio management service (Schwab Intelligent Portfolios) and has an advisory arm generating revenue from customer deposits. Plus, its own Schwab-branded mutual funds and ETFs are a source of recurring revenue both within the portfolios it manages and institutional and retail customers.

Bottom line

The big takeaway for investors? Diversification matters. The same approach that helps businesses withstand tough times eases volatility in your own portfolio and helps stabilize your returns.

Editorial Disclaimer: All investors are advised to conduct their own independent research into investment strategies before making an investment decision. In addition, investors are advised that past investment product performance is no guarantee of future price appreciation.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Research Alert: CFRA Downgrades Opinion On Shares On Li Auto Inc. To Sell From Hold
Research Alert: CFRA Downgrades Opinion On Shares On Li Auto Inc. To Sell From Hold
May 20, 2024
12:45 PM EDT, 05/20/2024 (MT Newswires) -- CFRA, an independent research provider, has provided MT Newswires with the following research alert. Analysts at CFRA have summarized their opinion as follows: We cut our 12-month target price to USD18 from USD50. The valuation reflects a 2024 P/B of 2x, a discount to Li Auto's ( LI ) 2020-2023 average P/B of...
Research Alert: CFRA Raises Opinion On Shares Of Restaurant Brands Intl. To Buy From Hold
Research Alert: CFRA Raises Opinion On Shares Of Restaurant Brands Intl. To Buy From Hold
May 20, 2024
08:55 AM EDT, 05/20/2024 (MT Newswires) -- CFRA, an independent research provider, has provided MT Newswires with the following research alert. Analysts at CFRA have summarized their opinion as follows: We raise our 12-month target price to C$120 from C$110, 24.9x our 2024 EPS, above QSR's 5-year average forward P/E of 22.1x, reflecting better revenue and earnings growth prospects. We...
Research Alert: CFRA Maintains Buy Opinion On Shares Of Nvidia Corporation
Research Alert: CFRA Maintains Buy Opinion On Shares Of Nvidia Corporation
May 20, 2024
12:50 AM EDT, 05/21/2024 (MT Newswires) -- CFRA, an independent research provider, has provided MT Newswires with the following research alert. Analysts at CFRA have summarized their opinion as follows: We up our 12-month target to $1,100 from $1,000, on a P/E of 35x our CY 25 EPS view, above peers but below historical given our view of improving FCF...
Research Alert: CFRA Upgrades Opinion On Shares Of Pentair Plc To Hold From Sell
Research Alert: CFRA Upgrades Opinion On Shares Of Pentair Plc To Hold From Sell
May 20, 2024
01:10 AM EDT, 05/21/2024 (MT Newswires) -- CFRA, an independent research provider, has provided MT Newswires with the following research alert. Analysts at CFRA have summarized their opinion as follows: We raise our 12-month price target to $85 from $75, valuing PNR shares at 18x our 2025 EPS forecast of $4.74 (up from $4.59; 2024 EPS estimate adjusted to $4.22...
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved