(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters.)
By Jamie McGeever
ORLANDO, Florida, March 27 (Reuters) - While auto
company shares around the world are wilting following U.S.
President Donald Trump's decision to slap aggressive tariffs on
imported cars, the currencies of the most-affected countries are
holding up surprisingly well.
Trump said on Wednesday that a 25% tariff on imported
vehicles will take effect on April 3. There will be some delays
and exemptions, of course, but this could potentially add
another $55 billion to the cost of finished vehicles.
The United States imported $220 billion of finished cars and
vehicles last year, of which 22% came from Mexico, 18% from
Japan, 17% from Korea, 13% from Canada and 11% from Germany.
Imports of all auto products totaled $474 billion.
Given these figures, the reaction of equity markets on
Thursday was unsurprising: shares of South Korea's Hyundai fell
4.3%, roughly three times more than the broader KOSPI's loss,
and some $16 billion was wiped off Japan's transport index.
German auto shares fell too, extending their losses to 10%
over the last three weeks, a period in which the broader DAX has
flat lined. Analysts at Morgan Stanley expect shares in "all
exposed" European auto companies to fall a further 5-7% in the
near term.
But the FX market's reaction was mixed. The Mexican peso
fell 1%, and both the yen and Canadian dollar slipped around
0.3%. But the euro and South Korean won rose 0.3%.
Indeed, the currencies of the four largest auto-exporters to
the U.S. - Mexico, Japan, Canada and South Korea - are all
stronger against the U.S. dollar so far this year. And with the
exception of the Korean won, they are also all up since Trump's
inauguration on January 20.
The euro is obviously a special case because it is shared by
20 countries and has been propelled higher in recent weeks by
Germany's fiscal pivot. Regardless, the euro is also firmer
against the greenback this year.
On the face of it, this is a head-scratcher. The hit to
these economies will be significant if the proposed tariffs are
fully implemented and kept in place for some time.
But zoom out a little further, and a clearer picture
emerges: one of U.S. dollar weakness.
A DOLLAR STORY
While the 'Tariff Man's' protectionist trade agenda could
have positive benefits for the U.S. economy over the long term,
the short-term impact is clearly negative. The tariff talk is
damaging U.S. consumer and business confidence, and market
sentiment, much more than these threats are hurting other
economies.
And U.S. consumers have reason to be skittish.
Morgan Stanley estimates that, all else being equal, the 25%
tariff on auto imports equates to a price increase of more than
$90 billion across the industry, or nearly $6,000 per unit on
average. Arthur Wheaton, director at Cornell's School of
Industrial and Labor Relations, reckons vehicle prices could
shoot up by as much as $20,000.
For a country that uses and loves cars as much as America,
that would be extremely painful.
Trump's tariffs also appear to be one reason overseas
investors are reassessing their U.S. assets. Foreign investors
are reducing exposure to Uncle Sam for economic, political and
valuation reasons. And non-dollar currencies are benefiting in
turn.
"It's mostly a capital flight story. The tariffs are bad for
Canada, Mexico and other countries, but investors are also
fleeing U.S. assets," says Brent Donnelly, president of trading
and analytics firm Spectra Markets.
The auto exporters' currencies aren't immune to the
escalating trade war. The Canadian dollar slumped to a four and
a half year low last month, and the peso could well come under
more pressure due to the auto sector's relatively large
footprint in Mexico's economy.
But right now, the currency feeling the whiplash most from
Trump's tariffs may be the U.S. dollar.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters.)