ORLANDO, Florida, June 3 (Reuters) - It is widely
believed that investors around the world have a
disproportionately high exposure to U.S. assets, particularly
stocks, an imbalance that could roil U.S. markets if corrected.
But what if these fears are overblown?
Several eye-popping statistics suggest that America's weight
in world financial markets is even greater than its outsized
economic might. Most strikingly, the U.S. net international
investment position (NIIP), or foreign investors' holdings of
U.S. assets less U.S. investors' holdings of overseas assets, at
the end of 2024 was $26 trillion. That's nearly 24% of global
GDP, up from 16% only two years earlier, a surge driven by
foreigners' insatiable appetite for U.S. equities, mainly "Big
Tech".
Demand was so hot that, by some measures, the value of
U.S.-listed stocks at the turn of the year represented 74% of
total global market cap. That share was 60% six years ago, and
less than half in 2011.
But the attractiveness of dollar-denominated assets is now
being questioned, as the often erratic policies of U.S.
President Donald Trump have upset longstanding economic and
geopolitical norms, making governments and investors question
whether Washington is still a reliable partner on the global
stage.
The concern is that this eroding confidence triggers a reversal
of the massive flows into Wall Street seen in recent years that
has damaging spillover effects.
Such a correction may not require outright selling. Given
the scale of the flows involved, just less buying among foreign
investors could be enough to cast a shadow over the world's most
important stock market.
And the running assumption is foreign investors don't have
the capacity or willingness to increase their exposure to U.S.
assets, creating a significant long-term downside risk for Wall
Street, Treasuries and the dollar.
"A structural shift is underway: the slow erosion of US economic
dominance," analysts at Deutsche Bank wrote on Monday.
SKEPTICAL
But looked at another way, foreign exposure to U.S. assets
may not be as high as initially meets the eye. That's the view
of analysts at JP Morgan, who measure portfolio investment in
U.S. bonds and equities as a share of countries' total household
sector financial assets.
They use a broad definition for a country's "household"
sector, covering investments by institutions like insurance
companies and pension funds that are ultimately made on behalf
of households. Using a broad range of data, from central banks,
U.S. Treasury and OECD household financial asset flows, they
measure the ratio of U.S. equity and bond holdings relative to
household financial assets in each country.
They find that "relative to the total financial assets of
households in the rest of the world, the allocations to U.S.
assets typically stand at around 10-20%." As a result, they are
"skeptical of the idea that foreign investors hold too much of
U.S. assets."
Given that U.S. equities account for more than 70% of the
MSCI global market cap and dollar-denominated bonds represent
around 50% of global bond indices, according to JP Morgan
estimates, the 10-20% exposure of foreign investors to U.S.
assets does appear surprisingly low.
And the 10-20% figure would be even lower were it not for
the outsized U.S. equity holdings at the Swiss National Bank and
Norway's sovereign wealth fund.
On the bond side, foreigners' footprint in the U.S. Treasury
market is shrinking. Data shows that they owned 31% of the
$28.55 trillion outstanding Treasury debt at the end of last
year. That share has been declining steadily since the Global
Financial Crisis. In 2008, the figure was approaching 60%.
Overseas investors' share of the T-bill market has shrunk
even more. In December, it was under 20%, near its lowest level
on record and sharply down from 50% a decade before.
Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou and his team at JP Morgan aren't
arguing investors will or should ramp up their purchases of U.S.
assets. And in cases where allocations are high - such as the
Taiwanese exposure to U.S. bonds or Canadians' holdings of U.S.
stocks - diversification would hardly be a surprise.
But there is "little indication" of broad-based selling of
U.S. assets by foreign investors so far this year, they note.
And if that selling does materialize, it may be far lighter than
many expect.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters)