ORLANDO, Florida, Nov 12 (Reuters) - The end of the
longest-ever U.S. government shutdown is in sight, which means
official economic data will soon be forthcoming. But even if
investors and the Federal Reserve are breathing a sigh of
relief, the signals they should soon get might not be all that
reliable.
Some of the delayed figures should begin to trickle out
quickly. Economists at Morgan Stanley predict the September
nonfarm payrolls report will probably be released a few days
after the shutdown ends, as the data has already been collected.
It will be much longer before the October report lands,
however, but when it does, it could be missing one key element:
the unemployment rate.
For the first time since 1948, the "household survey," from
which the unemployment rate is calculated, was not carried out
last month, according to Claudia Sahm, chief economist at New
Century Advisors. Unlike the "establishment survey" which
determines the monthly change in payroll jobs, subsequent
household surveys don't ask about prior months.
This data gap could factor into the U.S. central bank's
interest rate decision in December, as Fed Chair Jerome Powell
has made clear the labor market side of the central bank's dual
mandate has weighed more heavily on recent policy decisions than
inflation.
To be sure, what employment data the Fed does have to go on
is not painting a pretty picture. Based on private-sector data
and the limited government figures available, economists at
Goldman Sachs now reckon nonfarm payrolls declined by 50,000 in
October. That would be only the second monthly drop since
December 2020, and the biggest decline in more than five years.
A report last week from global outplacement firm Challenger,
Gray & Christmas showed planned layoffs soared to more than
150,000 in October, the highest reading for that month since
2003.
The Fed, however, may put its rate cuts on hold as long as
the official employment and other data remain incomplete and
potentially unreliable.
"What do you do if you're driving in the fog? You slow
down," Powell told reporters last month after the end of the
Fed's policy meeting.
INFLATION DISTORTION
The inflation and spending picture should remain hazy as
well.
Using the 2013 shutdown as a rough guideline, Morgan
Stanley's economists believe October inflation and consumer
spending data will not be released in time for the Fed's
December 9-10 policy meeting, never mind the November figures.
UBS economists are even more pessimistic about getting an
update on CPI inflation. They say the October report, originally
scheduled for Thursday, may not be released at all because the
Bureau of Labor Statistics was closed for the full month, so
price quotes were not collected.
Getting even deeper into the CPI weeds, UBS notes that
October data points are used as a base for some price index
calculations that affect other months. That means November,
December, and even April CPI inflation data could be distorted.
Meanwhile, there's a chance that October retail sales data
may also not be released before the Fed's next meeting.
According to UBS economists, retail sales data are collected by
mail, fax, or telephone, and aggregated within six business days
of the reference month. Was September's data collected?
"We could be without a key statistic for understanding a
large chunk of U.S. GDP for some time," they wrote on Friday.
Indeed, it's even possible that the unemployment and CPI
inflation rates for October are never released, because the data
were either partially collected or not collected at all.
So while the wave of relief lifting most stock markets this
week is understandable, the end of the shutdown should not be
confused with a return to economic clarity.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters)
Enjoying this column? Check out Reuters Open Interest (ROI),
your essential source for global financial commentary. ROI
delivers thought-provoking, data-driven analysis of everything
from swap rates to soybeans. Markets are moving faster than
ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn and X.