(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters.)
By Mike Dolan
LONDON, Aug 11 (Reuters) - Federal Reserve Chair Kevin
Warsh's battle to keep the central bank out of politics just got
harder. Any hope that U.S. President Donald Trump would give him
breathing room evaporated last week when the White House
targeted Fed Governor Lisa Cook, thrusting the central bank's
independence back into the spotlight.
Trump's renewed effort to remove Cook over unproven mortgage
fraud allegations suggests two things: the administration is
anxious that the Fed could raise interest rates as soon as next
month, and the president realizes his appointee as chair may be
unable to stop it, even if he wants to.
While public pressure on Cook could backfire and embolden her to
side with the hawks if Trump fails to remove her, there may also
be a calculation that it offers the president a scapegoat if
policy tightens at either of the two remaining meetings before
November's midterm elections. His counterpunch would then be
that any rate hike was a politically motivated move to defy him.
Futures markets see about a 75% chance of a quarter-point rate
increase by the midterms. Regardless of soft payrolls in July,
the main drivers are nearly six years of above-target inflation
and elevated core price rises, alongside the Iran-related energy
shock of the past six months. The outcome at the September 15-16
meeting is basically seen as a coin toss.
Friday's political swipe at Cook was likely mindful of exactly
that.
Trump's renewed effort to remove Cook took the form of a White
House letter saying he was "considering" her removal and
demanding a response within three weeks to what her attorney has
called "baseless" mortgage fraud allegations.The move came
despite a June Supreme Court ruling that recognized the Fed's
special statutory protections and left unresolved whether the
allegations constituted grounds for removal.
After a year of beating this drum, and even after the Supreme
Court pushback, Trump's deadline for Cook to clear her name is
just about three weeks before a critical Fed meeting where every
vote counts in the increasingly split committee.
"The issue of Fed independence has not yet been resolved," wrote
SGH Macro Advisors chief U.S. economist Tim Duy, adding that
this suggests Warsh is either unwilling or unable to back
Trump's long-standing push to slash rates in the face of
elevated inflation.
Warsh himself probably wishes he'd be given more room to
complete his reforms and make his own policy case both
internally and externally, especially given market disquietover
his vague inflation targets and his preference for less public
communication.
However, keeping his distance may prove difficult. The Wall
Street Journal reported last week that Trump has called the Fed
chair repeatedly since Warsh took the top job in May.
Late last month, Trump called Warsh "brilliant" and blamed the
rest of the board for not lowering rates immediately: "I know
he'd love to see lower interest rates, but he's got a board, and
it's a political board, and they want to keep rates up."
INFLATION RISK PREMIUM
Sorting out that board now seems to be a priority again at the
White House.
"If Trump succeeds and ultimately only the accusation of
wrongdoing and the ability to reply are all that is necessary to
replace Fed governors, expect appointees who are willing to
sharply lower rates like former Fed Governor Stephen Miran," Duy
said, explaining the upshot for markets and the economy.
As it stands, three members of this year's Federal Open Market
Committee (FOMC) voted to raise rates last month, while
governors Chris Waller and Cookvoted to hold rates steady,
though both have indicated the Fed may have to tighten to get
above-target inflation back to its 2% long-term goal.
If they were both to vote for a hike next month, the previous
9-3 split in favor of holding rates would become 7-5.
That would leave former Fed Chair and Trump nemesis Jerome
Powell - who remains on the board until his term ends in early
2028 - with the potential to divide the FOMC right down the
middle by switching from his previous vote to support a rate
rise.
Another big question is whether Warsh will publicly back
Cook, as Powell did in the absence of proven guilt.
How should markets react? Ahead of this week's consumer and
producer price inflation reports, the biggest influences on Fed
thinking, it is hard to get a clean view. Higher long-term
Treasury yields and a weaker dollar have
periodically emerged during intense bursts of the Fed
independence saga over the past 18 months, although it's unclear
whether investors see the issue as corrosive or a passing storm.
The most straightforward approach is to consider the impact of
fuzzier inflation goals from Warsh with renewed political
pressure to load the board with rate-cut advocates - a
combination that could aggravate long-term inflation risk
premiums in bond markets.
"If July marked the beginning of a deterioration in
confidence about the Fed's willingness to defend the inflation
target, the long end is dramatically under-pricing the risk,"
Barclays strategists noted this week, pointing to a noticeable
move in long-dated bond yields and inflation expectations after
Warsh's most recent press conference.
"We think that makes the next couple of weeks unusually
important. Medium- and long-term inflation compensation should
be watched closely to gauge how much damage, if any, was done to
the Fed's market credibility and confidence over the past week,"
they wrote, highlighting the five-year, five-year forward
inflation-linked swap.
Warsh could, of course, stamp his independence on the next
meeting by voting with the hawks. Without that unlikely outcome,
doubts about the Fed under his leadership - its commitment to
price stability and its distance from White House political
imperatives - will smolder at a dangerous time for the bond
market.
(The opinions expressed here are those of Mike Dolan, a
columnist for Reuters.)
Enjoying this column? Check out Reuters Open Interest (ROI),
your essential new source for global financial commentary.
Follow ROI on LinkedIn, and X.
And listen to the Morning Bid daily podcast on Apple, Spotify,
or the Reuters app. Subscribe to hear Reuters journalists
discuss the biggest news in markets and finance seven days a
week.