(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters.)
By Mike Dolan
LONDON, May 27 (Reuters) - U.S. stocks and bond yields
have been rising in tandem in recent weeks, with many investors
attributing the move to the Iran war, inflation and an AI arms
race. But some models now suggest higher borrowing costs are
reaching the point where they start to drag on equities.
Calculations on so-called equity risk premia (ERP) - the
excess returns promised by holding equities over those on
"risk-free" government bonds - differ widely depending on inputs
and methodologies.
Yet Societe Generale's proprietary version, which the bank
updated last week, reckons nominal U.S. Treasury yields at 4.5%
are a critical juncture for relative value between the two asset
classes.
The SG team finds the correlation between equity prices and
bond yields is not static and, historically, this link turns
strongly negative when bond yields push through 4.5%. Ten-year
Treasury yields broke through that level briefly
last week before hovering right on it on Tuesday, with the war
still unresolved.
"This essentially means that once U.S. Treasury yields are
above 4.5%, any further increase in bond yields is broadly
negative for equity markets," they wrote. The ability of U.S.
equities to absorb higher bond yields, they added, is now
limited.
That puts the next steps in the Iran conflict and the
disrupted Strait of Hormuz at a potential tipping point for
broader financial markets through midyear.
Since the war started on February 28, the 10-year yield has
climbed by more than 50 basis points. Equities juddered on the
initial oil shock but have since bounced back almost 20%, lifted
by a technical ceasefire at the start of April and a sharp
upgrade in AI-related profit estimates during the U.S. earnings
season.
With U.S. inflation running hot and Federal Reserve
officials turning hawkish, bond yields have taken another sharp
leg higher this month. Oil analysts doubt that even an immediate
end to the war would resolve all supply problems this year. The
risk for central banks is that entrenched inflation forces them
to tighten monetary policy further.
And at current levels of longer-term bond yields, we may be
at an inflection point for stocks as well.
SocGen calculates the U.S. equity risk premium has fallen to
about 3.5% - close to the 3% threshold where it sees equities
starting to struggle against more attractive bond returns.
MODELS AND FRAMEWORKS
In context, the ERP was above 7% after U.S. interest rates
were cut to zero following the banking crash in 2008 and the
COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, and stood above 5% before the Fed's
rate-hike campaign in 2022.
To understand how SG arrives at its figures: the U.S. cost
of equity has remained above 7.8% this year. That expected
return is the discount rate at which the present value of all
future dividends equals the current index level.
SG's dividend discount model is divided into four stages.
The first three years are taken from consensus earnings
forecasts; the next three are drawn from 10-year average
earnings growth; then a nine-year period of linear decline to
what it defines as a "perpetual" earnings growth rate equivalent
to the 10-year average nominal GDP growth rate.
Any sudden downshift in these inputs, from a growth or
earnings surprise, for example, would put the ERP in the danger
zone even without further bond yield gains.
But that's just one model. Others are signalling alarm
already.
JPMorgan's proxy for the ERP, which it sees as the gap
between the equity discount rate of the S&P 500 and the
real 10-year Treasury yield, has fallen to just 2.2% - a level
it says is a new low for the post-financial-crisis period since
2007.
That is 90 basis points below JPM's long-term historical
average.
"While it is still some way above its 2000 trough, this
implies that there is currently more limited room before a
further rise in bond yields starts becoming a problem for the
equity market and that from a long-term asset allocation point
of view," JPM strategist Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou wrote.
There are differences in the models, obviously. JPM uses a
two-stage dividend discount model and a real Treasury yield
adjusted for rolling inflation expectations.
But both are clearly signalling that the AI-led equity boom
faces a harder road at current yield levels.
The AI theme has swept away myriad market concerns over the
past three years. Unless the Iran conflict ends swiftly - and
fixes a smouldering inflation and interest rate problem with it
- the AI rally may have a great deal more sweeping to do.
(The opinions expressed here are those of Mike Dolan, a
columnist for Reuters.)
Enjoying this column? Check out Reuters Open Interest
(ROI), your essential new source for global financial
commentary.
Follow ROI on LinkedIn, and X.
And listen to the Morning Bid daily podcast on Apple, Spotify,
or the Reuters app. Subscribe to hear Reuters journalists
discuss the biggest news in markets and finance seven days a
week.