financetom
Politics
financetom
/
Politics
/
SC to examine if government can pass orders against CBI chief: Here's what experts have to say
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
SC to examine if government can pass orders against CBI chief: Here's what experts have to say
Nov 29, 2018 12:53 PM

The Supreme Court on Thursday commenced its hearing on ousted Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) director Alok Verma's plea against the central vigilance commission (CVC's) decision to divest him of his powers and send him on temporary leave.

The Supreme Court said it would first consider whether the government has the power to divest the CBI director of his duties under whatever circumstances or whether the selection committee headed by the prime minister must be approached before moving against Verma on corruption allegations involving him.

Fali Nariman, Verma's counsel, said Verma was appointed as CBI chief for a fixed tenure of two years and cannot even be transferred.

Nariman submitted if at all there was any proposal to clip the wings of the CBI director, then the proposal should have first gone to the selection committee or the government should have moved the court.

In a reply, the Chief Justice of India (CJI) said that if it becomes necessary to take note of the CVC report then the government will have to submit its response for the same.

The Supreme Court has decided to adjourn the hearing till December 5.

CNBC-TV18 caught up with Aishwarya Bhati, advocate, Supreme Court and Shantanu Sen, former joint director, CBI to discuss the court proceedings.

Aishwarya Bhati said, "I am clearly of the view that the manner in which things have happened, it is not that somebody has been removed from the post. Protection of tenure is a very important feature and that is what has come out of the Supreme Court judgement."

Here the allegations are of corruption, had these important people indulged in some criminal activities, would it still be that they would be immune? That kind of immunity is not available under the rule of law, Bhati said.

"In fact, I must tell you that here this tenure protection is under the Supreme Court orders. The constitution protects the tenure of High Court and Supreme Court judges in our system," Bhati added.

Shantanu Sen said it stands to reason that a person against whom serious charges have been made and we have no doubt that serious charges were made by number two against number one and he made very serious charges and registered an FIR.

Now when they are under inquiry, they should be moved out from the position, not transferred out, not thrown away somewhere else, they stay there but they are subject to inquiry, Sen added.

With inputs from PTI.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Lok Sabha passes Forest (Conservation) Amendment Bill — All you need to know
Lok Sabha passes Forest (Conservation) Amendment Bill — All you need to know
Jul 11, 2023
Activists have contended that words like "ecotourism facilities" and "any other purposes" are too vague and may pave the way for widespread exploitation and misuse.
Brahmapuram waste plant fire: Kerala Assembly witnesses uproarious scenes, LoP says CM running away from issue
Brahmapuram waste plant fire: Kerala Assembly witnesses uproarious scenes, LoP says CM running away from issue
Mar 13, 2023
A fire that broke out at the waste treatment plant in Kochi on March 2, 2023, continues to spread toxic fumes even after 11 days of the incident. The Kerala government has said that 95 percent of the fire has been extinguished, but the smoke from the landfill has not entirely subsided. 
What is the debate over Biodiversity Bill, likely to be tabled in monsoon session of Parliament
What is the debate over Biodiversity Bill, likely to be tabled in monsoon session of Parliament
Jul 12, 2023
The new bill exempts registered AYUSH practitioners and people accessing codified traditional knowledge, from sharing benefits with local communities or giving prior intimation to state biodiversity boards before accessing biological resources.
Govt blames inaction by AAP in Punjab, Delhi for bad air quality
Govt blames inaction by AAP in Punjab, Delhi for bad air quality
Nov 6, 2023
Accusing Kejriwal of being busy with election campaigning in poll-bound states and waking up to the situation late, Minister of State for Consumer Affairs, Food, and Public Distribution, Ashwini Kumar Choubey, said that the Centre had held a meeting with Chief Secretaries and senior officials from four North Indian states on 20th October to discuss measures to reduce air pollution, which he claims weren't adopted by the AAP-led governments.
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved