ORLANDO, Florida, July 15 (Reuters) - The astonishing
rebound in stocks since early April largely reflects investors'
bet that U.S. President Donald Trump won't follow through on his
tariff threats.
But the market's very resilience may encourage the president
to push forward, which could be bad news for equities in both
the U.S. and Europe.
Investors appear to believe that the April 2 "reciprocal"
tariffs were mostly a tactic to bring countries to the
negotiating table, and Washington's levies will end up being
much lower than advertised. Tariffs may end up much higher than
they were before Trump's second term began, but the situation
will still be better than the worst-case scenarios initially
priced in after Trump's so-called "Liberation Day".
Monday's equity moves were a case in point. Trump's threat
on Saturday to impose 30% levies on imports from the European
Union and Mexico - two of America's largest trading partners -
was met with a collective market shrug. European and Mexican
stocks dipped a bit, but Wall Street closed in the green and the
Nasdaq hit a new high.
This follows threats in recent days to place a 50% tariff
rate on goods imported from Brazil and a 35% levy on goods from
Canada not covered under the USMCA agreement. Brazilian stocks
have slipped 5%, but Canadian stocks have hit new peaks.
The question now is whether the line between complacency and
the "TACO" trade - the bet that "Trump always chickens out" - is
getting blurred.
GETTING STRETCHED
The scale of the recovery since April 7 is truly
eye-popping. It took the S&P 500 less than three months to move
from the April bear market lows to a new all-time high, as
Charlie Bilello, chief market strategist at Creative Planning,
recently noted on X. This was the second-fastest recovery in the
last 75 years, only bested by the bear market recovery in 1982
that took less than two months.
On a 12-month forward earnings basis, the S&P 500 index is
now near its highest level in years and well above its long-term
average. The tech sector, which has propelled the rally, has
rarely been more expensive in the last quarter century either.
None of that means further gains cannot materialize, and one
could argue that the valuations are justified if AI truly
delivers the promised world-changing productivity gains.
Regardless, it is hard to argue that the rally since April
is not rooted in the belief that tariffs will be significantly
lower than the levels announced on Liberation Day.
If many countries' levies do end up around 10% like
Britain's and the aggregate rate settles around 15%, then equity
pricing might very well be reasonable. But if that's not the
case, growth forecasts will likely have to be revised a lot
lower.
"We stay overweight U.S. stocks, but don't rule out more
sharp near-term market moves. Uncertainty on who will bear
tariff costs means yet more dispersion in returns - and more
opportunity to earn alpha, or above-benchmark returns,"
BlackRock Investment Institute analysts wrote on Monday.
DOOM LOOP?
One concern is that a loop is potentially being created,
whereby Wall Street's resilience and strength in the face of
heightened trade uncertainty actually emboldens Trump to double
down on tariffs.
Most analysts still believe cooler heads will prevail,
however. Trump's tolerance for equity and bond market stress,
and therefore U.S. economic pain, appears "limited", according
to Barclays.
But if markets have gotten too complacent and Trump does
increase tariffs on EU goods to 30%, potential retaliation would
risk a repeat of something similar to the post-Liberation Day
selloff, sending European equities down by double digits,
Barclays warns.
It may also be that when it comes to tariffs, investors are
focusing so intently on China that not much else moves the dial.
This may be short-sighted though.
China accounted for 13.4% of U.S. goods imports last year,
the lowest in 20 years. In contrast, the U.S. imported $605.7
billion of goods from the European Union, or 18.6% of all
imports and the most from any single jurisdiction.
As Trump sees it, Europe is "ripping off" America almost as
much as China.
Bilateral U.S.-China trade last year totaled $582 billion,
compared with bilateral U.S.-EU trade flows of $975 billion,
U.S. Census data shows. America's $235.9 billion goods deficit
with the EU was smaller than its $295.5 billion gaps with China,
but that's still comfortably America's second-biggest trade
deficit.
If Trump doesn't back down in his standoff with Europe, Wall
Street might have to.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters)