financetom
World
financetom
/
World
/
Explained | Why a no-fly zone is unlikely in Ukraine
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Explained | Why a no-fly zone is unlikely in Ukraine
Mar 5, 2022 2:23 AM

Russia's attack on Ukraine's Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant has renewed calls for NATO to impose a no-fly zone over Ukraine, despite the repeated rejection of the idea by western leaders concerned about triggering a wider war in Europe.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on Friday asked the people of Western Europe to demand that their leaders change course because the shelling of a nuclear power plant in Ukraine threatens the security of the entire continent.

Immediate closure of the skies over Ukraine is needed, he said. Take to the streets and say that you want to live, to live on earth without radioactive contamination. Radiation does not know where the Russian border is.

The attack did not, as initially feared, result in radiation release.

But military analysts say there is no chance that the U.S., Britain and their European allies will impose a no-fly zone because it could easily escalate the war in Ukraine into a nuclear confrontation between NATO and Russia. Here's a more detailed explanation about the situation:

WHAT IS A NO-FLY ZONE?

A no-fly zone would bar all unauthorized aircraft from flying over Ukraine. Western nations imposed such restrictions over parts of Iraq for more than a decade following the 1991 Gulf War, during the civil war in Bosnia and Herzegovina from 1993-95, and during the Libyan civil war in 2011.

WHY WON'T NATO TAKE THIS STEP IN UKRAINE?

In simple terms, because it would risk a direct military conflict with Russia that could escalate into a wider European war with a nuclear-armed superpower.

While the idea may have captured the public imagination, declaring a no-fly zone could force NATO pilots to shoot down Russian aircraft.

But it goes beyond that. In addition to fighter planes, NATO would have to deploy refueling tankers and electronic-surveillance aircraft to support the mission. To protect these relatively slow, high-flying planes, NATO would have to destroy surface-to-air missile batteries in Russia and Belarus, again risking a broader conflict.

Also Read | Analysis: Russian attacks spur debate about nuclear power as climate fix

The only way to implement a no-fly zone is to send NATO fighter planes into Ukrainian airspace, and then impose that no-fly zone by shooting down Russian planes, NATO Secretary Jens Stoltenberg said Friday. We understand the desperation, but we also believe that if we did that, we would end up with something that could end in a full-fledged war in Europe.

We have a responsibility as NATO allies to prevent this war from escalating beyond Ukraine, he said.

WHAT WOULD A NO-FLY ZONE ACHIEVE?

Ukrainian authorities and people cowering night after night in bomb shelters say a no-fly zone would protect civilians and now nuclear power stations from Russian air strikes.

But analysts say it's Russias ground forces, not aircraft, that are causing most of the damage in Ukraine.

What Ukrainians actually want is a broader intervention like the one that occurred in Libya in 2011, when NATO forces launched attacks on government positions, said Justin Bronk, a research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute in London. That's not likely to happen when the opponent is Russia.

They want to see the West kind of sweeping in and taking out the rocket artillery that's pummeling Ukrainian cities, Bronk said. Were not going to go to war against the Russian army. They are a massive nuclear-armed power. There is no way that we could possibly model, let alone control, the escalation chain that would come from such an action.

WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE SKIES OVER UKRAINE?

Predictions that Russia would quickly control the skies over Ukraine have not come to fruition.

Military experts are wondering why Russia has chosen to leave most of its fixed-wing combat aircraft on the ground during this massive land offensive. One explanation may be that Russian pilots aren't well trained in supporting large-scale land operations, engagements that require coordination with artillery, helicopters and other assets in a fast-moving environment.

I think that maybe they're a little bit worried that that is a very constrained area. It's not like the Middle East, where there's all kinds of space to roam around in the air, said Robert Latif, a retired U.S. Air Force major general who now teaches at the University of Notre Dame.

They could very easily stray over borders," he explained. "With both Ukrainian and Russian air defense systems and Ukrainian, what little they have, and Russian airplanes all flying around that could be a very confusing. I think maybe they're a little bit worried about actually being able to pull it off.

Follow latest updates on the Russia-Ukraine war here

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
GLOBAL MARKETS-Nasdaq tumbles, Treasuries dip amid earnings, geopolitical crosscurrents
GLOBAL MARKETS-Nasdaq tumbles, Treasuries dip amid earnings, geopolitical crosscurrents
Apr 19, 2024
(Updates to 16:04 EDT) By Stephen Culp NEW YORK, April 19 (Reuters) - The Nasdaq and the S&P 500 closed sharply lower on Friday and Treasury yields dipped as investors juggled lackluster earnings, uncertainties surrounding central bank policy and geopolitical strife. Gold and crude oil prices advanced as market participants kept an uneasy eye on unfolding turmoil in the Middle...
CANADA STOCKS-TSX pares weekly decline as interest rate sensitive shares gain
CANADA STOCKS-TSX pares weekly decline as interest rate sensitive shares gain
Apr 19, 2024
* TSX ends up 0.5% at 21,807.37 * For the week, the index falls 0.4% * Communications sector gains 0.6% * Financials add 0.7% (Updates at market close) By Fergal Smith April 19 (Reuters) - Canada's main stock index edged higher on Friday as energy and interest rate sensitive shares notched gains, with the index outperforming Wall Street and clawing...
CANADA FX DEBT-C$ notches weekly gain as market works off oversold position
CANADA FX DEBT-C$ notches weekly gain as market works off oversold position
Apr 19, 2024
* Canadian dollar gains 0.1% against the greenback * For the week, the currency was up 0.2% * Price of U.S. oil increases 0.7% * Bond yields edge lower across the curve By Fergal Smith TORONTO, April 19 (Reuters) - The Canadian dollar strengthened against its U.S. counterpart on Friday as oil prices rose and the market took stock of...
EMERGING MARKETS-Latam markets steady as geopolitical fears calm; EM stocks set for worst week since June
EMERGING MARKETS-Latam markets steady as geopolitical fears calm; EM stocks set for worst week since June
Apr 19, 2024
* Chile cenbank to cut interest rate by 50bps in May: poll * Mexican inflation coming from abroad -finance official * Mexican peso recovers from 5% plunge * Latam FX up 0.6%, stocks add 1.1% (Updated at 3:45pm ET/1945 GMT) By Bansari Mayur Kamdar April 19 (Reuters) - Latin American stocks and currencies steadied on Friday, recovering from early losses...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved