ORLANDO, Florida, Nov 3 (Reuters) - Wall Street was
mixed on Monday, with bumper corporate dealmaking activity and
another mega AI-related tie-up offset by murky signals around
the path for U.S. growth and interest rates, while the dollar
crept up to a fresh three-month high.
In my column today, I look at whether Big Tech's big spend
on AI will generate the big returns investors are clearly hoping
for. No one has a crystal ball, of course, but the huge sums
being spent mean the bar for decent returns is very high too.
If you have more time to read, here are a few articles I
recommend to help you make sense of what happened in markets
today.
1. OpenAI turns to Amazon ( AMZN ) in $38 billion cloud
services
deal after restructuring
2. Kimberly-Clark bets $40 billion for Kenvue
despite
Tylenol controversy
3. PREVIEW-No surprises seen in US debt issuance:
T-Bills
up, bonds steady
4. Fed's T-bill pivot expected to ease supply, but
rate
futures flag tight funding
5. Creeping AI leverage may tap nerve in Treasuries:
Mike
Dolan
Today's Key Market Moves
* STOCKS: Wall Street mixed. Strong gains in Asia,
Kospi
leaps to new highs. Argentina's Merval hits new record, up
nearly 50% since Milei's mid-term election win. Brazil's Bovespa
tops 150,000 for first time.
* SHARES/SECTORS: Kenvue +12%, Amazon ( AMZN ) +4%,
Kimberly-Clark
-14.5%. Consumer discretionaries +1.7%, tech +0.4%; energy, real
estate, consumer staples -0.5%.
* FX: Dollar index hits 3-month high, eyes break
above
100.0. Argentine peso -2% towards recent record low, bitcoin
-3%.
* BONDS: U.S. yields +2 bps at long end, curve bear
steepens.
* COMMODITIES/METALS: Gold holds steady, as does oil
despite OPEC+ plans to pause output increases.
Today's Talking Points
* Tech debt
In September, Oracle tapped the bond market for $18
billion, last week Meta announced its largest ever bond sale of
up to $30 billion, and on Monday Google's owner Alphabet said it
is raising debt finance. Media reports put the multi-tranche
issue at around $22 billion.
Investors are lining up to lend to these tech giants, of
course, but the borrowing does raise questions around how much
their collective AI capex splurge is eating into cash flows. If
Big Tech borrows big in the months ahead, could that affect
demand for U.S. Treasury debt?
* Do you want to make a deal?
Kimberly-Clark is buying Band-Aid maker Kenvue in a deal
worth nearly $50 billion, something of a surprise move given the
premium paid and some of the controversies and difficulties
facing Kenvue.
Dealmaking appetite is strong - Wall Street is booming, the
Fed is cutting rates, and financial conditions are the loosest
in years. Deals targeting U.S.-based companies totaled $1.7
trillion, according to LSEG, up 36% year-on-year and second
highest since LSEG records began in 1970. Justified, or is
irrational exuberance creeping in?
* Fed fissures
Uncertainty around the Fed's next step is rising, and
understandably so. The U.S. government shutdown is about to
extend to a record-matching 35 days on Tuesday, and online
betting market Polymarket is predicting it won't end until
December 2.
No data means very little visibility. Add to that the
growing differences between FOMC hawks and doves, and little
wonder the probability of a December cut has slumped to 65% from
90% last week. Few would bet against it being closer to a 50-50
call soon.
Big Tech, big spend. But big returns?
The reaction of most "Magnificent Seven" tech giants' shares
to their latest earnings suggests the artificial intelligence
boom is far from over. Yet doubts about the future returns from
these firms' astronomical AI expenditures are gnawing deeper.
The third-quarter earnings season has seen these tech
behemoths continue to rake in huge profits and offer sunny
guidance. Some investors may baulk at the Mag 7's lofty
valuations, but today's tech leaders - unlike the superstar
firms of the 1990s dotcom bubble - appear to have sustainable
business models. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell reiterated
as much last week, saying that their AI investments are a major
source of U.S. economic growth.
Just four "hyperscalers" alone - Microsoft ( MSFT ), Amazon ( AMZN )
, Meta and Alphabet - are expected
to spend a combined $350 billion this year, and Goldman Sachs
estimates global AI-related infrastructure spending could reach
$4 trillion by 2030.
The more these firms splurge on data centers, cloud
computing capabilities, and the gamut of AI technologies, the
loftier investors' expectations will get. At some point, they
will be impossible to meet.
The financial benefits and cost savings for society
resulting from that are one thing; which companies actually
profit is another. It is important, therefore, to distinguish
between "value creation" and "value capture".
"The value creation is certainly there," says Daniel Keum,
associate professor of management at Columbia Business School.
"But will that value flow back to the companies that are making
these AI investments right now? For me, the clear answer is no."
DO THE MATH
It's early days in the AI supercycle, but Big Tech's AI
outlays are already eating into hyperscalers' cash flows.
Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management,
estimates that aggregate capex at Amazon ( AMZN ), Google, Microsoft ( MSFT ),
Meta and Oracle as a share of their operating cash flow is now a
record 60% - and rising.
Amazon ( AMZN ) reported strong earnings last week, and its stock
surged double digits to hit a new high on Friday. But buried in
the report was a slide showing that trailing-12-month free cash
flow has fallen almost 70% over the last year.
Ross Hendricks, analyst at independent research firm Porter
& Co, estimates that hyperscalers' free cash flow in the first
quarter of next year will be down more than 40% from the same
period this year.
"The whole sector faces the same basic problem," says Bob
Elliott, co-founder of Unlimited Funds. "The math is pretty
simple, unless there is a surge in revenues from these
activities, Big Tech is going to pump nearly all their free cash
flow into capex in just a few years."
This creates several potential problems. It intensifies the
pressure to generate high returns on these investments, but
until those materialize, non-AI-related activities are also
under pressure to produce significant returns. And this leaves
hyperscalers vulnerable in the event of a sharp economic or
market downturn.
HIGHER BAR
The fate of these megacaps will, of course, have a
significant impact on the broader economy, not only because
these companies' capex is helping to drive growth but also
because almost everyone with a retirement fund is exposed to
them. Nvidia's share of the total S&P 500 market cap is a
stunning 8%, while that of the "Mag 7" is a record 37%.
Investors are well aware of how much these shares have
appreciated. The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index has more than
doubled from its April low. But expensive markets can always get
more expensive.
It will take a brave fund manager to tell clients that
they're reducing exposure to what have effectively become
cash-printing machines. Of course, whether these companies can
continue printing money as fast as they're spending it is the
big question.
For example, Meta's announced capex this year is around $70
billion, but Unlimited Funds' Elliott notes that the company's
income is only $3 billion to $5 billion higher, based on
underlying trends, than it was before they started spending all
this cash. That's a pretty "mediocre" return on investment.
Of course, CEO Mark Zuckerberg might argue that this is
long-term investment and that not spending now could be more
costly down the line if the AI revolution lives up to the hype.
But it is unclear how much patience investors will have.
Smaller businesses overall seem to be faring better. A
Wharton Business School study published last month found that
74% of businesses say generative AI investment is already
producing positive returns, especially smaller enterprises in
digital-based sectors like tech and finance.
"Confidence remains strong ... but future gains must now be
justified by clear performance outcomes," the authors said.
The bar for Big Tech giants with market caps of trillions of
dollars and capex budgets of hundreds of billions is higher
though. Much higher.
What could move markets tomorrow?
* Australia interest rate decision
* Japan PMI (October, final)
* Japan corporate earnings
* European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde speaks
* Canada trade (October)
* U.S. earnings, including Advanced Micro Devices, Uber,
Pfizer,
Spotify
Want to receive Trading Day in your inbox every weekday
morning? Sign up for my newsletter here.
Opinions expressed are those of the author. They do not
reflect the views of Reuters News, which, under the Trust
Principles, is committed to integrity, independence, and freedom
from bias.
(By Jamie McGeever;)