BERLIN, Feb 13 (Reuters) - The German army's
battle-readiness is less than when Russia invaded Ukraine in
2022, military officials, lawmakers and defence experts told
Reuters.
Even if a new government boosts defence spending, it will
remain hamstrung for years, particularly by a lack of air
defence, artillery and soldiers, they said.
"Before Russia's invasion of Ukraine, we had eight brigades
at around 65% readiness," Colonel Andre Wuestner, head of the
German Armed Forces Association, told Reuters in an interview.
Sending weapons, ammunition and equipment to Ukraine, as well as
accelerating Germany's own drills, took a toll on the available
equipment, he said.
"Together, this means the German land forces are down to a
readiness of around 50%," he said.
Chancellor Olaf Scholz promised after Russia's invasion to
overhaul Germany's decrepit military, but three years later a
pledge to provide the NATO alliance with two divisions -
typically around 40,000 troops - by 2025 and 2027 faces major
setbacks, more than a dozen military officials, lawmakers and
defence experts said.
The details revealed by the sources, some of whom spoke on
condition of anonymity as they discussed classified military
information, underscore Berlin's precarious position as Europe
faces a new geopolitical era under U.S. President Donald Trump.
Germany, alongside Poland, is tasked by NATO with providing
the bulk of ground forces that would act as first responders to
any Russian attack on the alliance's eastern flank.
Scholz's historic pledge to bring about a Zeitenwende, or
turning point, in Germany's approach to its military has not
worked, the sources said, blaming a lack of a sense of urgency,
a dysfunctional procurement system and strained finances.
Berlin has failed to fully equip troops for a division for
NATO by the start of this year, and in any case has no air
defences to support them, the sources said.
Its pledge for a NATO division by 2027 is "long out of our
reach," said a military source.
That second division is only about 20% equipped, according
to opposition lawmaker Ingo Gaedechens, a defence expert on
parliament's budget committee.
"Even if we were to order everything now, we would not get
it equipped in time," said Gaedechens. Polls suggest his
Christian Democrats (CDU) party, headed by candidate chancellor
Friedrich Merz, will lead a new government after Germany's
February 23 election.
TRUMP'S DEMANDS
The extent of Germany's weakness comes to light as President
Trump is pushing Europe to shoulder more of its own defence
burden and Washington talks of a deal to end the war in Ukraine,
which would put even more demands on Germany's military if they
have to police a truce.
Trump said on Wednesday that he had spoken with Russian
President Vladimir Putin about starting negotiations immediately
to end the war in Ukraine.
All Germany's mainstream parties have pledged to keep
military spending at NATO's required minimum of 2% of GDP
. Trump wants NATO members to more than double their
spending targets to 5% of GDP from 2%, and NATO is considering
raising its military spending target to around 3%.
Germany's current Defence Minister Boris Pistorius said last
month military expenditures of around 3% of GDP will be
necessary to make the Bundeswehr ready for war, but has said
Trump's 5% target would amount to more than 40% of Germany's
total government spending.
Whoever wins the election will in any case face severe
challenges after 2027 when the 100 billion euro ($104 billion)
special fund will be exhausted. Germany will need around 30
billion euros per year from then on to reach the 2% target.
"Now there are only problems everywhere and no solutions,"
Gaedechens said.
The most glaring example is air defence, which "needs to be
solved most urgently," Johann Wadephul, deputy leader of the
CDU/CSU conservative faction in parliament responsible for
defence topics, told Reuters.
Defence experts say the war in Ukraine has demonstrated the
importance of drones and artillery - large guns operated by
crews. The Bundeswehr is lagging on both.
On drones, "the Bundeswehr has nothing at all," said
Wadephul. "So we are practically empty-handed."
He called for easier procurement standards and a rise in
defence spending to 3% of GDP. He and the CDU also want Germany
to reintroduce conscription, which the country suspended in
2011.
A spokesperson for Scholz did not respond directly to a
request for comment on the assertion the Zeitenwende had failed,
but pointed to remarks Scholz made in February. Then he said a
national debate on how to fund more defence spending was
"somewhat irritating," and called for a deal to ease Germany's
tight restrictions on debt to cover the cost.
Germany was already facing a shortfall in funding its
needs, he said then, adding that it was "almost spooky that
there is no discussion about how we will pay for it."
The defence ministry declined to comment on the state of
the army's readiness, saying it was classified information. But
a spokesperson added that Germany's land forces have been
"providing a combat-ready division in high availability" to
fulfil NATO missions at short notice on its eastern flank since
January 1, 2025.
A NATO spokesperson said Scholz's Zeitenwende had made a big
difference to Germany's security and the strength of the
alliance. Increasing defence spending was one of its top
priorities although there is more to do, they added.
"THE SNOOZE BUTTON"
Russian President Vladimir Putin is ramping up his forces to
1.5 million troops as he aims to be capable of fighting in two
different theatres.
Wuestner, the colonel, said Germany is far from the only
European state to be slow to respond to Russia's military
incursions into Ukraine since 2014, but "in particular we
Germans hit the snooze button."
Defence ranks third after immigration and the state of the
economy in what Germans see as the most pressing problems for
the new government, according to a survey by public broadcaster
ARD published in January.
In 2021, Germany agreed to provide 10 brigades - units
of some 5,000 troops - for NATO - by 2030. It now has eight and
is building up a ninth in Lithuania to be ready from 2027.
In summer, NATO is set to agree more demanding targets to
adapt to the deteriorating security situation; Germany is
expected to the be asked to provide at least two more brigades,
two experts told Reuters.
The German NATO division that was meant to be ready this
year is not fully operational as - after donations to Ukraine -
it lacks 155mm howitzers, its main weapons system, and had to
cannibalize some artillery pieces for spare parts, a military
and a parliamentary source told Reuters.
Around 80 advanced RCH 155 howitzers needed for the 2027
second division have not yet been ordered.
Both the divisions also need around 200 short-range air
defences, such as Gepard anti-aircraft tanks, to protect them
from drones and aircraft, according to two military sources and
a parliamentary one.
To save money, Germany decommissioned the Gepard in 2012 and
is only slowly starting to replace it, with deliveries of an
initial order of 19 Rheinmetall Skyrangers expected in 2027 and
2028.
"We won't have the air defences for the division 2025 up and
running before 2029," the military source warned.
"BLED OUT WITHIN MONTHS"
During the Cold War, Germany spent between 3% and 4.5% of
GDP on defence and maintained 500,000 troops and 800,000 reserve
forces. But the Bundeswehr has not met a target of 203,000
troops set in 2018, and it is currently short-staffed by some
20,000 regular troops, according to defence ministry data.
Since conscription was suspended in 2011, it also needs more
reservists. Scholz's government introduced a law in November
obliging young men to fill in a questionnaire on their readiness
to fight, and Berlin's goal is to eventually reach 200,000 more
reservists.
This would enable Germany to swiftly expand its troops to
around 460,000 in the event of war - nearly double what it could
muster today.
"Given the casualty rates we are calculating with, the
Bundeswehr will be bled out within months," said CDU lawmaker
Roderich Kiesewetter, who was a colonel in the German forces
before turning to politics. He declined to disclose what those
rates are.
His CDU colleague Wadephul said Germany needs a combat-ready
military with some 250,000 troops and 500,000 reserve forces.
According to the latest polls, a coalition of the CDU and
the SPD is the most likely election outcome.
Smaller, radical parties AfD and BSW could potentially form
a blocking minority of one third of the seats in parliament, and
prevent agreement on new special funds to bankroll higher
investment into the Bundeswehr.
And the military's readiness would be tested if Trump
strikes a deal on Ukraine that includes Europe providing troops
to secure a ceasefire.
"If you take a look at the length of the frontline, how many
brigades will we have to provide?" asked Joe Weingarten, a
lawmaker with the SPD who specializes in defence topics.
"This would come on top of everything."
($1 = 0.9604 euros)