*
Italian police raid Amazon ( AMZN ) sites in probe of Chinese goods
*
Prosecutors see Amazon ( AMZN ) as 'Trojan horse' for tax-free
imports
*
Smuggling, tax probes may spread to other EU states,
sources say
(Adds further details of Italian investigation paragraphs
13-14, probe expected to spread to other EU nations paragraphs
15-16, further background on Amazon ( AMZN ) investigations paragraphs
19-23)
By Emilio Parodi
MILAN, Nov 24 (Reuters) - Italian police carried out
searches and seizures at two Amazon ( AMZN ) sites in Italy on
Monday as part of an investigation into the alleged smuggling of
Chinese goods, three people with direct knowledge of the matter
said.
Dozens of officers from the Guardia di Finanza tax police
and the customs agency seized around 5,000 products at a
logistics hub operated by the e-commerce giant in Cividate al
Piano, in the northern province of Bergamo, the sources said.
At Amazon's ( AMZN ) Italian headquarters in central Milan, police
seized IT equipment and identified the Amazon ( AMZN ) manager
responsible for the transportation of goods within Italy, the
sources added.
Amazon ( AMZN ) in Italy was not immediately available for comment.
NEW LINE OF INQUIRY STEMMING FROM PREVIOUS CASE
Italian prosecutors allege that Amazon ( AMZN ) acts as a kind of
"Trojan horse" allowing an as yet unknown number of Chinese
goods to circulate in Italy without being appropriately taxed, a
court document showed on Monday.
Among the products seized at the Bergamo centre were toys,
mobile phone covers, air fryers, pens and small scissors.
It was not immediately clear what impact the two operations
would have on Amazon's ( AMZN ) activities in Italy.
The smuggling probe is a new line of inquiry stemming from
an investigation into an alleged 1.2 billion euro tax evasion
case.
The new case, led by Milan prosecutors together with the
Monza branch of the Guardia di Finanza, alleges smuggling
offences by dozens of Italian companies, many of which are
believed to be fronts for Chinese entities, and the manager in
charge of the movement of goods via Amazon ( AMZN ).
Prosecutors suspect that goods are being brought from China
into the European Union, and then into Italy, through currently
unknown channels, without sales taxes or customs duties being
paid.
The products are then allegedly moved and sold in Italy via
Amazon's ( AMZN ) marketplace.
Milan prosecutors are investigating both suspected smuggling
and violations of the EU customs code.
PROBE EXPECTED TO EXPAND TO OTHER EU NATIONS, SOURCES SAY
Since last summer, two other ongoing operations have
proceeded with Amazon's ( AMZN ) cooperation due to the complexity of
managing goods flows in the e-commerce giant's logistics hubs.
Three people with direct knowledge of the matter said the
number of products involved could total half a million, with the
probe expected to be extended to the rest of the European Union.
Milan prosecutors were summoned to The Hague headquarters of
the EU agency for criminal justice cooperation Eurojust in July,
where they presented the scope of their investigation to
counterparts from several EU countries, including Germany,
France, the Netherlands, Poland, Spain, Belgium, Sweden and
Ireland.
Disputes over customs duties and sales taxes have fueled
growing tensions with the United States over the past year, but
it is unclear how this case involving China will be viewed in
Washington and Brussels.
TAX EVASION: EU PROSECUTORS ALSO INVESTIGATING
In the original 1.2 billion euro tax evasion case, Milan
prosecutors investigated three managers and Amazon's ( AMZN )
Luxembourg-based European unit over alleged tax fraud related to
online sales in Italy between 2019 and 2021.
According to the probe, Amazon's ( AMZN ) algorithm allows it to sell
in Italy goods from non-EU sources, mostly Chinese, without
disclosing their identity, helping them avoid paying Italian
sales taxes.
Under Italian law, an intermediary offering goods for sale
in Italy is jointly liable for non-payment of sales taxes by
non-EU sellers using its e-commerce platform.
Amazon ( AMZN ) said in a previous statement that it was "committed
to complying with all applicable tax laws".
In relation to that case, Italy's tax agency has submitted a
settlement proposal to Amazon ( AMZN ) on which the U.S. group must
decide by December.
Amazon's ( AMZN ) tax position has also been investigated by the
European Public Prosecutor's Office (EPPO), which has opened its
probe into its accounts between 2021 and 2024 after new EU rules
imposing stricter VAT obligations on marketplaces came into
force.