financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
Analysis-Musk convincing Tesla investors to back his pay. Now he must persuade a judge
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Analysis-Musk convincing Tesla investors to back his pay. Now he must persuade a judge
Jun 12, 2024 11:21 PM

WILMINGTON, Delaware (Reuters) - Tesla appears to have convinced an army of small investors and major funds to ratify Elon Musk's $56 billion pay package. Now comes the harder part: persuading an already skeptical Delaware judge to recognize it.

Musk on Wednesday evening said that shareholders were voting in favor of both the pay package and a board-sponsored move of Tesla's legal home to Texas from Delaware. Official vote results are due at the company's annual meeting on Thursday.

Musk is the driving force of Tesla and responsible for many of its advances, leading to vocal support for the pay package especially among small shareholders. Still, sales and stock price have fallen recently, adding to concerns that produced a concerted 'no' vote.

Before Tesla can give shares to Musk, there will likely be months of litigation over the pay ratification vote, Musk's efforts to rally shareholders in support of his compensation and the appeal of the original ruling, four months after a Delaware judge voided the pay package.

A final legal result in Musk's favor is not certain and will not be quick.

Judge Kathaleen McCormick of Delaware's Court of Chancery rescinded the pay package in January because she found that Musk improperly controlled the 2018 board process to negotiate it. She also ruled that Tesla failed to fully inform investors before they voted for it.

"A vote by shareholders wouldn't cause an automatic reversal of Chancellor McCormick's decision. We are in uncharted waters here," said Samantha Crispin, corporate attorney at Baker Botts.

As Tesla sees it, Thursday's shareholder vote essentially reached back in time and corrected the 2018 shareholder vote by disclosing enormous amounts of information to investors, including McCormick's 200-page ruling.

Tesla argued it corrected the problem of Musk's domination of the process to negotiate the pay package as well. It created a special committee eventually composed only of Kathleen Wilson-Thompson, an independent board member, who reviewed the 2018 pay deal and decided it was in the best interest of shareholders.

But Tesla also acknowledged in securities filings that a favorable ratification might not resolve the pay dispute. Ratification is primarily seen as a tool for fixing problems such as technical glitches in corporate documents.

Many major shareholders and some smaller ones voted against the pay package, frustrated by the size of the award, slowing business at Tesla and Musk's growing list of distractions, including businesses in rockets, AI, social media, neuroscience and tunnel digging.

At least one shareholder has already filed a legal challenge to the vote.

The lawsuit in Delaware's Court of Chancery by Tesla investor Donald Ball accused Musk of using "strong-arm, coercive tactics" to get his pay package approved. It cited Musk messages on his X social media platform saying he was uncomfortable transforming Tesla into an AI leader unless he had 25% of the company's stock, almost double his current holdings.

But Tesla and Musk will likely argue that Musk is allowed to express his desire to leave the company.

Columbia Law School Professor Zohar Goshen said he thought the Delaware court decision should reverse itself after a yes vote, but acknowledged the situation was too unusual to say.

"It is hard to estimate how the court will rule because there is too much noise around this decision. But my personal view is that Tesla should succeed," Goshen said.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Investors wait to see Red Sea in shippers' Q1 numbers
Investors wait to see Red Sea in shippers' Q1 numbers
May 1, 2024
(Reuters) - European shipping firms Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd are unlikely to get a big boost from soaring freight rates due to the Red Sea crisis in the first quarter, reinforcing worries about overcapacity in the long run. Spot freight rates tripled to almost $3,500 a container after vessels began avoiding the Red Sea due to attacks by Houthi militants, the...
Stellantis Completes $1.07 Billion Share Buyback Tranche
Stellantis Completes $1.07 Billion Share Buyback Tranche
May 1, 2024
04:59 AM EDT, 05/01/2024 (MT Newswires) -- Stellantis ( STLA ) said Wednesday it has completed the first 1 billion euros ($1.07 billion) tranche of its share buyback program launched Feb. 28. From Feb. 28 to April 29, the automobile manufacturer purchased nearly 41.1 million common shares. Price: 22.23, Change: -0.07, Percent Change: -0.31 ...
Update: Starbucks Fiscal Q2 Non-GAAP Earnings, Revenue Decline; Shares Slump Premarket
Update: Starbucks Fiscal Q2 Non-GAAP Earnings, Revenue Decline; Shares Slump Premarket
May 1, 2024
04:54 AM EDT, 05/01/2024 (MT Newswires) -- (Updates with the stock move in the headline and the first paragraph.) Starbucks ( SBUX ) shares sank more than 12% in premarket activity Wednesday after the company reported fiscal Q2 adjusted earnings and sales that missed the market's expectations. The company reported fiscal Q2 non-GAAP earnings late Tuesday of $0.68 per share,...
Update: AMD Q1 Non-GAAP Earnings, Sales Narrowly Beat Expectations; Q2 Revenue Outlook in Line; Shares Fall Premarket
Update: AMD Q1 Non-GAAP Earnings, Sales Narrowly Beat Expectations; Q2 Revenue Outlook in Line; Shares Fall Premarket
May 1, 2024
04:46 AM EDT, 05/01/2024 (MT Newswires) -- (Updates with the stock move in the headline and the first paragraph.) AMD (AMD) shares fell nearly 7% pre-bell Wednesday after the company reported a narrow beat on adjusted earnings and sales in Q1. The company reported Q1 non-GAAP earnings late Tuesday of $0.62 per diluted share, up from $0.60 a year earlier....
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved