By Tim McLaughlin
Sept 30 (Reuters) - The three largest U.S. energy
exploration companies paid more than $42 billion to foreign
governments last year, about eight times more than what they
paid in the United States, according to regulatory filings.
The disclosures from Exxon Mobil ( XOM ), Chevron Corp ( CVX )
, and ConocoPhillips ( COP ) were required this year for
the first time ever under a new Securities and Exchange
Commission requirement.
Transparency advocates had been pushing for the rule for
more than a decade to shine a light on Big Oil's foreign
financial transactions in its global quest for oil, and provide
a sense of whether U.S. taxpayers are getting a fair share of
the value of soaring U.S. production.
The United States has become the world's largest oil and gas
producer in recent years, thanks mainly to a boom in the massive
Permian Basin in Texas and New Mexico.
"The truth is, here in the U.S., we get one of the worst
deals for the extraction of our natural resources," said
Michelle Harrison, deputy general counsel for EarthRights
International, an environmental advocacy group.
About 90% of Exxon's nearly $25 billion in global payments
went to foreign governments in 2023, even though close to a
quarter of Exxon's global exploration and production earnings
come from the United States.
The Texas-based oil giant paid out $22.5 billion in taxes,
royalties and other items overseas, with the United Arab
Emirates ($7.4 billion), Indonesia ($4.6 billion) and Malaysia
($3.2 billion) topping the list, according to the disclosures.
By contrast, Exxon made about $2.3 billion in U.S.-based
payments in 2023, including just $1.2 billion to the U.S.
Internal Revenue Service, according to Exxon's report.
Exxon's U.S.-based upstream earnings totaled $4.2 billion,
compared to $17.1 billion in non-U.S. markets, according to
Exxon's 2023 annual report.
In the preamble of Exxon's SEC report, the company
complained that comparisons between U.S. and overseas payments
were not fair and said U.S. government payments totaled $6.6
billion last year when you include more than $4 billion in state
and local taxes omitted by the regulations.
Exxon declined to comment further.
Chevron ( CVX ), meanwhile, paid $14.6 billion to foreign
governments in 2023, including $4 billion to Australia alone,
according to the filings. The company paid just $2 billion in
the U.S., according to the filings.
A Chevron ( CVX ) spokesperson said the company's overhead in the
U.S. can be much lower than in overseas oil fields.
Chevron's ( CVX ) holdings in the Permian Basin, for example, total
about 2.2 million acres with about 75% of that land connected to
either low or no royalty payments. Chevron ( CVX ) executives see that
as a huge advantage and one that creates shareholder value,
according to presentations by the company.
Last year, most of Chevron's ( CVX ) upstream profits were from
international markets - at $17.4 billion compared to $4.1
billion in the United States - according to Chevron's ( CVX ) 2023
annual report.
Chevron ( CVX ) did not criticize the disclosure parameters in its
filing, and told Reuters it would continue to work with relevant
agencies toward transparency and accountability between
governments and the industry.
For ConocoPhillips ( COP ), just $1.3 billion of a total $6.5
billion in total global payments last year went to the U.S.,
according to the disclosures.
The company declined to comment.
Section 1504 of the Dodd-Frank Act opened the door for the
new disclosures around overseas activities by energy exploration
and production companies.
A divided SEC adopted the rules in 2020 in a 3-2 vote, as
the burgeoning ESG movement, which focuses on environmental,
social and governance matters, demanded more transparency on
behalf of millions of U.S. investors.
The adoption of the rule, however, came after a pitched
years-long battle: A federal court in 2013 vacated the SEC's
first attempt at imposing the mandate, and Congress blocked a
second attempt in 2017.
Company US payments Overseas ($B) Total ($B)
($B)
Exxon $2.3 $22.5 $24.8
Chevron $2.0 $14.6 $16.6
ConocoPhillips $1.3 $5.2 $6.5
Total $5.8 $42.3 $47.9