*
Deal could boost competition but may reduce services and
increase costs, say opponents
*
Capital One commits $265 billion over five years to
lending,
philanthropy, and investment
*
Community support could positively affect regulators'
views, M&A
experts say
By Michelle Price, Pete Schroeder
WASHINGTON, July 19 (Reuters) - Capital One CEO
Richard Fairbank and other executives went head-to-head with
community groups at a public meeting on Friday convened by
regulators to discuss the bank's tie-up with Discover Financial
Services ( DFS ).
Unveiled in February, the $35 billion deal will create the
biggest U.S. credit card issuer by balances, the sixth-largest
bank by assets, and will give Capital One control of Discover's
card payment network, the fourth major payment network
operator.
Virginia-based Capital One and other proponents say the deal
could boost card payments competition but opponents fear it will
reduce services, increase costs for Americans and threaten
financial stability by creating another too-big-to-fail bank.
"We believe this acquisition advances financial stability
and increases competition in the industry, while also providing
significant new benefits in the communities in which we
operate," said Fairbank in opening remarks at the all-day
hearing.
The Federal Reserve and Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency (OCC), which are under political pressure to be tough
on mergers, are holding Friday's meeting in a rare move reserved
for the most contentious merger reviews.
The meeting offers a forum for the public to weigh in on the
deal, giving opponents an opportunity to ramp up pressure on
regulators.
Top congressional Democrat Maxine Waters was scheduled to
speak against the deal, according to the Fed's agenda, along
with a slew of community and advocacy groups.
"This merger is a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad
idea," said Jesse Van Tol, CEO of the National Community
Reinvestment Coalition, a powerful coalition of nonprofits. He
cited financial stability concerns and worries the deal would
ultimately hurt consumers.
Reuters reported on Wednesday that Capital One had committed
$265 billion over five years to lending, philanthropy and
investment if the takeover goes through, as it tries to appease
critics and win over regulators.
That community benefits plan is more than twice as big as
any to date, according the NCRC which negotiated all previous
plans. Van Tol dismissed the plan on Friday, saying it largely
comprises credit card and auto lending that the banks already
provide.
Speaking to Reuters this week, Andres Navarrete, Capital
One's head of external affairs, said he believed the regulators
care deeply about the plan, and that credit card and auto loans
are key products for consumers that meet essential needs.
The Fed and OCC assess the deal's impact on the convenience
and needs of affected communities, as well as financial
stability, and competition, among other issues. The Justice
Department also provides its view on the antitrust implications.
That process could take several more months, said regulatory
experts.
Beyond Capital One and Discover executives, several Virginia
state lawmakers and advocacy groups are expected to speak in
favor of the deal, according to the agenda. Vocal support from
civil rights or community groups could be helpful for Capital
One.
"Community support ... positively affects the regulators'
views of the transaction," said Chip MacDonald, an M&A lawyer
and managing director at MacDonald Partners.
"Where antitrust concerns are present, this could also be a
basis for a bank regulator finding that the public benefits of
the merger outweigh the competitive concerns."