* Engine spending at six U.S. airline operations far
outpaced flying since 2019
* Some newer engines need heavier, costlier repairs
* Replacement-engine leases can outlast repairs
* Aircraft delivery delays prolong maintenance on older jets
By Rajesh Kumar Singh
CHICAGO, Aug 14 (Reuters) - Airlines are getting grounded
jets back into the air. The bills left by a years-long engine
crisis are proving much harder to bring down.
Air New Zealand ( ANZFF ) offers a glimpse of how those costs
can linger. Engine problems at one point left as much as 20% of
its fleet unavailable, forcing it to lease extra aircraft and
engines to protect its schedule.
Availability has since improved sharply, but Chief Executive
Nikhil Ravishankar told Reuters it could take 12 to 18 months to
shed the extra leases and related costs, only partly offset by
supplier compensation.
The crisis was fueled by durability problems affecting some
newer engines and a Pratt & Whitney powder-metal problem that
forced accelerated inspections and removals, compounded by
shortages of labor, parts and repair capacity. Airlines leased
replacement engines and aircraft to keep flying, leaving them
with higher overhaul, parts and lease costs even as groundings
ease.
Delayed deliveries from Boeing ( BA ) and Airbus
are adding to the pressure by keeping older jets in service
longer and pushing some airlines into engine work they had
expected to avoid.
A Reuters analysis of U.S. Transportation Department data
found that across six large U.S. airline operations, reported
spending on engine labor, aircraft-engine repairs and engine
materials rose about 68% between 2019 and 2025, while hours
flown increased about 10%.
The same pattern appeared in the latest available
Transportation Department data, with reported spending in those
categories up 17% in the first quarter from a year earlier while
hours flown increased less than 2%.
Maintenance spending can vary with engine age, accumulated
cycles, fleet-management decisions and the timing of shop
visits, during which engines are removed from aircraft for
inspection or repair. The Transportation Department data do not
identify what caused the increase.
GE Aerospace, Safran and RTX did not
respond to requests for comment. Rolls-Royce declined to
comment.
RTX's Pratt & Whitney illustrates the disconnect. Groundings
tied to its geared-turbofan engines, which power many newer
single-aisle jets, fell 25% in the first half. But in the second
quarter, the mix of heavier PW1100G repair work was 14
percentage points higher than a year earlier.
Latest regulatory filings from United Airlines and
American Airlines ( AAL ) also show higher first-half
maintenance expenses driven partly by engine-overhaul work.
Parts and other materials account for about 60% of the direct
cost of a typical single-aisle engine overhaul, according to
consultancy Oliver Wyman. Newer engines deliver fuel-efficiency
gains, but overhaul bills are higher because they have fewer
developed repair options and fewer used parts available, partner
Sam Sargent said.
George Dimitroff, head of valuations at Ascend by Cirium, said
overhaul and mandatory parts-replacement costs for newer LEAP
and GTF engines, which power most Airbus A320neo- and Boeing 737
MAX-family jets, have risen about twice as much since 2019 as
for older CFM56 and V2500 engines.
Not all the maintenance growth on newer engines is tied to
technical problems; maturing fleets also require more scheduled
work.
LEASES OUTLAST GROUNDINGS
Long shop visits can force airlines to lease replacement
engines.
JetBlue Airways ( JBLU ) has said some Pratt engines can
take 200 to 300 days to complete a shop visit. The airline has
also increased the number of engines it leases.
Short-term leases for some newer LEAP and PW1100G engines
have exceeded $6,500 a day in completed transactions over the
past year, compared with around $5,000 a day in 2022-23,
according to aviation consultancy IBA.
Austin Willis, CEO of engine lessor Willis Lease Finance ( WLFC )
, told Reuters airlines needing replacement engines have
often sought leases lasting around three years, while shorter
contracts are frequently extended. That can leave airlines
paying even after their own engines return.
OLD JETS, NEW BILLS
A full overhaul of a CFM56-5B engine used on older Airbus
A320-family jets can easily cost more than $10 million, Willis
said.
Oliver Wyman and the International Air Transport Association
estimated that delayed aircraft replacements could have added
about $3.1 billion to global airline maintenance costs in 2025.
Delayed aircraft retirements are also tightening the supply
of cheaper used engine parts. Industry officials and experts say
fewer engines are being dismantled for parts, pushing up
used-parts prices and leaving airlines more dependent on new
parts from manufacturers.
PRICING TENSIONS
The squeeze has sharpened tensions between airlines and engine
makers over repair costs and pricing.
Asked at the International Air Transport Association annual
meeting in June whether engine makers had too much pricing power
and were using shortages to charge airlines more, United Chief
Executive Scott Kirby replied: "Yes and yes."
Industry executives say developing new technology costs
billions of dollars and manufacturers often discount engines
heavily upfront, expecting to recover that investment over years
through parts and maintenance.
Safran CEO Olivier Andriès last month said increases in
repair and spare-parts prices should be moderate and reflect
higher supplier costs rather than an "abusive posture."
GE Aerospace CEO Larry Culp said last month that
LEAP-related aircraft groundings had fallen to near zero. GE is
also rolling out upgraded parts designed to let the engines stay
on aircraft longer before needing major maintenance.
RTX, which said it is improving durability and expanding
repair capacity, reported Pratt's PW1100G repair output rose 43%
in the second quarter from a year earlier and turnaround times
fell 23%.
For airlines, the financial relief can take longer.
"The fact that AOGs (aircraft on ground) have come down,
that doesn't change the maintenance cost," Willis said.