By Arathy Somasekhar
HOUSTON, April 22 (Reuters) - As U.S. shale oil boomed
last decade, an oil pipeline company pitched an ambitious
multi-billion-dollar export port off the Texas coast to ship
domestic crude to buyers in Europe and Asia.
In April, Enterprise Products Partners' ( EPD ) SPOT became
the first project to receive a license from the U.S. maritime
regulator for a deepwater port that could load two supertankers,
each of which can carry up to 2 million barrels of oil at a
time.
But multi-year regulatory delays, a loss of commercial
backers and slowing U.S. shale production has left SPOT, or Sea
Port Oil Terminal, and its three rival projects without any
secured customers, energy industry executives say.
"There are a lot of gray areas right now with export
projects," said Zack Van Everen, an oil analyst at energy
investment banker Tudor Pickering Holt & Co.
Enterprise declined to make an executive available for
an interview, but said it continues to develop the project.
Shale producers and traders rely on ports to get their oil
to market and are balking at the higher-than-expected loading
fees for new projects even if they are able to fully load
supertankers, executives said.
HIGHER COSTS
SPOT, proposed for a point 30 miles off the Gulf coast in
2019, is the only Texas deepwater project with its government
approvals. But its cost has soared to about $3 billion, two
industry experts said, from an original estimate of $1.85
billion for Enterprise.
It has no long-term customer contracts, or joint venture
partners, stalling a financial green light from the company,
sources said. The project, if approved, is currently expected to
start up in 2027.
A customer willing to commit the largest volume is being
offered a $1 per barrel rate by Enterprise to load at SPOT oil
transferred from its Houston storage terminal, three people
familiar the terms said. Clients with smaller loads have been
offered an about $1.20 a barrel fee.
That compares with the all-in cost of about 75 cents per
barrel to load in Corpus Christi, Texas, the top U.S. oil export
port, a source familiar with export operations said.
To sweeten the deal, Enterprise is offering preferential
terms for loading schedules, and may bundle some of its other
services to make the price more competitive, two of the people
said.
Enterprise disputed the fees, but declined to provide
the project's cost and the per barrel terms.
A deepwater port allows customers to load oil directly onto
a supertanker, eliminating the additional cost of loading the
oil on smaller ships at shallower ports and then transferring
the crude from the smaller vessels to larger ones.
But it has lost Chevron ( CVX ) as an early backer because
of the regulatory delays to secure a license, and Canadian oil
pipeline operator Enbridge ( ENB ) has released its option to take a
stake in SPOT, Enterprise said.
Chevron ( CVX ) declined to comment on commercial matters.
An Enbridge ( ENB ) spokesperson said it views SPOT "as a valuable
option for our Canadian heavy crude customers to be able to
access the project," but declined further comment.
LESS NEED FOR DEEPWATER PORTS
U.S. exports of crude rose to a peak of 5.6 million bpd in
February 2023, and existing facilities can handle as much as
another 1.5 million barrels, though port congestion could limit
that number, according to RBN Energy. Russia's invasion of
Ukraine also has shifted global flows with more U.S. vessels
going to Europe instead of Asia, which were primarily geared to
using supertankers.
"The short-term dynamic is less need for big ship capacity,
which actually fits the current U.S. export capacity a lot
better," Colin Parfitt, Chevron's ( CVX ) vice president of midstream,
said in an interview in March.
Changing flows and slowing shale output gains have created
uncertainty for shippers. "That's changed the dynamic a little
about how people want these (deepwater ports)," Parfitt said.
"If you get one built, it is going to crowd out the others."
Currently, there is one U.S. offshore port - called the
Louisiana Offshore Oil Port - that can fully load supertankers.
However it primarily handles oil produced in the Gulf of Mexico
and has few pipes that link to the top U.S. shale field, the
Permian, in West Texas.
SPOT's largest target would be moving shale oil, and those
output gains have slowed dramatically. U.S production is
expected to rise 280,000 barrels per day to 13.21 million bpd
this year, according to the U.S. Energy Information
Administration. That compared with a one-year gain of 1.6
million bpd in 2018.
Enterprise said this month that it projects growth in and
around the Permian basin past 2030.
Consolidation among top shale players, like Exxon Mobil's ( XOM )
recent purchase of Pioneer Natural Resources ( PXD ),
also took away customers for Enterprise and other players, with
some of the largest shale drillers already holding long-term
contracts with existing export facilities.
Of the three other deepwater port projects along the Texas
coast, private-equity backed Sentinel Midstream, oil refiner
Phillips 66 and pipeline operator Energy Transfer ( ET )
each have sought U.S. approvals for offshore ports. So far, none
have received licenses.
"Between the current dock capacity along the U.S. Gulf
Coast, and the most aggressive production projections, it
appears that one, at most two," could proceed, said oil export
consultant Brett Hunter of Energy Hunter LLC.