*
Critics warn government stakes limit corporate strategy,
market
agility
*
Analysts also raised questions about how the Intel ( INTC ) deal
will
affect customers
*
White House says US needs to develop more production
capacity in
critical industries
By David Gaffen and Susan Heavey
WASHINGTON, Aug 25 (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald
Trump said he wants to make more investments in healthy U.S.
companies on Monday. Whether Corporate America is on board is
another story.
The White House announced a near-10% stake in chipmaker Intel ( INTC )
on Friday that converts government grants into an
equity share.
Trump on Monday doubled down on the idea of deals in other
sectors similar to the one announced with Intel ( INTC ).
The administration's approach does away with decades of
thinking about the U.S. economy, where the government took
corporate stakes in rare emergencies like the 2008 global
financial crisis and the subsequent bailout of U.S. auto
companies. Intel ( INTC ) is struggling, but it still has a cash cushion
of $9 billion and a market value of $105 billion.
To critics, the Intel ( INTC ) move - along with the White House's
full-court press to get the U.S. Federal Reserve to lower
interest rates, its use of emergency powers to slap tariffs on
imported goods and involvement in different mergers - threatens
the business world's nimbleness.
"We're moving from a pure capitalistic economy to a much
more state-engaged economy. ... That's a huge change for America
and over where we've been. I've never seen an era like this,"
said Bill George, former Medtronic CEO and executive education
fellow at Harvard Business School.
"I will make deals like that for our Country all day long,"
Trump said in a post on Truth Social on Monday, touting the
company's rising stock price.
Trump said in his post that he would help companies that make
similar "lucrative" deals with U.S. states, but didn't provide
details. Intel ( INTC ) had promised to use the CHIPS Act money to build
plants in the United States.
However, the risks of the government's involvement are no more
apparent than in Intel's ( INTC ) own regulatory filing on Monday, where
it laid out several new risk factors to having the government
invested in the company - from potentially harming international
sales, to limiting the chipmaker's ability to secure future
government grants, or subjecting the company to additional
regulations or restrictions in other countries.
Intel ( INTC ) CEO Lip-Bu Tan went a step further in a video posted
on Monday by the Commerce Department, saying, "I don't need the
grant."
He added: "But I really look forward to having the U.S.
government be my shareholder."
Analysts also raised questions about how the Intel ( INTC ) deal will
affect customers.
"Is it conceivable that as part of something like this the
administration might 'encourage' customers to use Intel's ( INTC )
capacity?" Bernstein analyst Stacy Rasgon wrote in a note on
Tuesday.
Intel ( INTC ) is not the only company where Trump has become personally
involved.
The White House intervened to complete the purchase of U.S.
Steel by Japan's Nippon Steel in June, taking what Trump called
a "golden share" that gives Washington say over its operations.
It took a stake in rare earths company MP Materials ( MP ) as
well, and on Monday, White House economic advisor Kevin Hassett
said the government could take additional stakes in other
companies.
"Companies that are nationalized in whole or in part don't
do as well, because they're restricted from making the kinds of
strategic decisions that would be solely market-based," said
Nell Minow, chair of Portland, Maine-based ValueEdge Advisors.
The White House argues that the United States needs to
develop more production capacity in critical industries rather
than outsource that manufacturing to other countries.
Numerous CEOs met with Trump shortly after his re-election in
November 2024, and that parade of visitors has continued into
his term. It has yielded the likes of Apple ( AAPL ) CEO Tim
Cook giving Trump a present of a customized souvenir plaque with
a 24-karat gold base mined from Utah earlier in the month.
Apple ( AAPL ) - one of the biggest companies in the world, with a market
value north of $3 trillion - has been trying to shift production
away from China, which Trump targeted in his first-term trade
war, to India, a move Trump has also criticized. Apple ( AAPL ) has
announced roughly $600 billion in planned investment in the
United States, though the White House has suggested it could
also build smartphones domestically.
The United States does not have significant capacity to make
smartphones.
"I think companies are just starting to realize, how much
control do you want to give up and how much ownership do you
want to give up to the government?" George said.