March 21 (Reuters) - Mergers that could result in banks
with more than $100 billion in assets should expect heightened
scrutiny from the U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,
according to a policy statement the top bank regulator proposed
on Thursday.
The FDIC's board of directors voted 3-2 to issue the
proposal, which would update the agency's merger guidance for
the first time in 16 years. The new guidance puts special
emphasis on maintaining the stability of the banking sector,
agency officials said in advance of the vote.
Bank mergers and industry consolidation have come under
intense scrutiny since last year, when three of the largest-ever
U.S. bank failures resulted in acquisitions and billions in
losses for the FDIC's insurance fund.
"The bank failures of 2023 underscore the risks that banks
with assets over $100 billion can have for financial stability,"
FDIC Chair Martin Gruenberg said at a public meeting ahead of
the vote.
Republican board members, however, opposed the proposal
saying it would make the process less predictable and entrench
what they called institutional bias against bank mergers.
Jonathan McKernan, a Republican member of the board, said
adding hurdles to mergers resulting in banks above $100 billion
could discourage the creation of new competitors to established
Wall Street giants.
"One of the potential unintended consequences...is that we
continue to enhance this moat of regulatory protection around
our largest banks," he said.
In a statement, the Bank Policy Institute, a major trade
group in Washington, said the new guidance continued "an
alarming trend" among regulators of discouraging bank mergers
and acquisitions and that its "subjective" standards would make
the merger review process more uncertain.
The draft proposal, which offers a statement of principles
rather than set procedures, says officials would also focus on
other financial stability concerns, such as whether a merged
bank would add complexity to the financial system and the extent
of its cross-border activities.
The changes reflect statutes adopted by Congress in 2010
under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform legislation, according
to the proposal, which is now subject to a 60-day period of
public comment.
Financial reform advocates such as Democratic Senator
Elizabeth Warren have expressed outrage that regulators allowed
Wall Street giant JPMorgan Chase & CO ( JPM ), already the
nation's largest bank, to acquire the failed First Republic Bank ( FRCB )
last year.
Despite misgivings about New York Community Bank's
exposure to commercial real estate and earlier concerns from
FDIC officials, the U.S. Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency, another banking regulator, in 2022 approved its merger
with Flagstar Bank of Michigan.
Regulators then approved NYCB's takeover of the failed
Signature Bank ( SBNY ) last year. The combined entity reported
a surprise loss in January and received a $1 billion capital
infusion this month a group of investors, including former U.S.
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin.