May 8 (Reuters) - Wedding-dress designer and influencer
Hayley Paige Gutman convinced a New York federal court on
Wednesday to give her total control of "Hayley Paige"
social-media accounts amid her dispute with JLM Couture ( JLMCQ ) over
their broken partnership.
U.S. District Judge Laura Swain reversed her previous
decision that gave wedding-dress maker JLM sole control of the
Instagram and Pinterest accounts but upheld an order banning
Gutman from using the "Hayley Paige" name and promoting or
selling competing dresses for five years.
JLM attorney Sarah Matz of Adelman Matz in a statement said
the social-media decision was "not meaningful" and involved an
"empty" Instagram account, as "all of the important aspects of
the injunction and prior rulings remain in place."
Gutman's attorneys at Haynes and Boone said in a statement
that they are "thrilled for Ms. Gutman and her million-plus
followers."
Gutman, who has since changed her professional name to
Cheval, was the maker of "Hayley Paige" wedding dresses until
2020. She signed on to design dresses for New York-based JLM in
2011.
JLM said in its 2020 lawsuit that Gutman locked the company
out of "Hayley Paige" social media, promoted products from other
companies and violated a noncompetition agreement after contract
negotiations broke down.
U.S. District Judge Laura Swain granted JLM a preliminary
injunction in 2021 that blocked Gutman from competing with the
company until the end of their contract, gave JLM control of
"Hayley Paige" social-media accounts and prevented her from
using the "Hayley Paige" name in advertising.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed part of
Swain's decision in January but told the judge to reconsider who
should control the accounts and whether the noncompetition
agreement was too restrictive. Swain gave JLM and Gutman joint
access to the accounts in a March ruling.
Swain on Wednesday dissolved her order that granted JLM
control of "Hayley Paige" social media, and said that the
evidence indicated that Gutman originally owned the accounts and
never transferred them to the company.
The judge also affirmed that Gutman could not compete with
JLM until the end of the noncompetition agreement in December
2025.
The case is JLM Couture Inc ( JLMCQ ) v. Gutman, U.S. District Court
for the Southern District of New York, No. 1:20-cv-10575.
For JLM: Sarah Matz and Gary Adelman of Adelman Matz
For Gutman: Joe Lawlor, Richard Rochford and Tiffany Cooke
of Haynes & Boone
Read more:
Dressmaker can block designer Hayley Paige from using her
own name trademark, court says
Hayley Paige wedding-dress dispute again sent back to
federal court
(Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington)