financetom
Economy
financetom
/
Economy
/
The jobs data revisions that cost a US government statistician her job
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
The jobs data revisions that cost a US government statistician her job
Aug 4, 2025 10:26 AM

(Reuters) -The revisions to previous estimates of the size of U.S. payrolls gains for May and June that prompted President Donald Trump to fire Bureau of Labor Statistics Commissioner Erika McEntarfer on Friday were by any measure extraordinarily large.

Indeed, the combined downward revision for the two months of 258,000 was the largest - outside of those during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic - since at least 1979. 

Here's a quick graphical breakdown:

FIRST REVISION

The monthly nonfarm payrolls report, released typically on the first Friday of each month, includes an initial estimate of employment changes for the immediately preceding month and revisions to the earlier estimates for the prior two months. BLS makes the revisions because more survey responses come in over the ensuing weeks and because it updates the seasonal factors affecting each month's estimates.

The BLS on Friday said 133,000 fewer jobs had been created in June than first estimated. Over the last several years, the first estimate of the net change in payrolls each month has been revised lower more often than not. 

It has been revised down in eight of the last 12 BLS reports over the last year.

The downward revision on Friday was the largest since the first estimate of payrolls gains for March 2021, published in April 2021, was revised down by 146,000 a month later. Over the last three years through June, the median estimate revision was -10,000. That contrasts with a median increase of 8,000 during the decade before the pandemic and a median increase of 2,000 over the series history since 1979.

SECOND REVISION

The total for May's payroll gains was revised lower by 125,000 in Friday's report, when the third estimate for payrolls for that month was published. That figure was the largest downward reduction of payrolls gains for a second revision - outside of the pandemic era - since the estimate for March 1983 was revised down by 127,000 in the report published in June 1983.     

COMBINED REVISION

The combined downward revision for the two previous months - May and June - was larger than anything reported outside of the pandemic era. Indeed, the estimates for the two prior months combined have more often than not been revised higher. Since 1979, the median two-month combined estimate change was an upward revision of 10,000.

Measured in absolute terms - revisions in either direction - Friday's revision also stands out. There have only been four larger revisions: +709,000 for November and December 2021; -642,000 for March and April 2020; +285,000 for August and September 1983; and +414,000 for April and May 1981.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Fed's Logan calls for 'gradual' rate cuts, says 'should not rush'
Fed's Logan calls for 'gradual' rate cuts, says 'should not rush'
Oct 10, 2024
(Reuters) - Dallas Federal Reserve Bank President Lorie Logan on Wednesday said she supported last month's outsized interest-rate cut but wants smaller reductions ahead, given still real upside risks to inflation and meaningful uncertainties over the economic outlook. Following last month's half-percentage-point cut in the fed funds rate, a more gradual path back to a normal policy stance will likely...
Fed's Logan calls for 'gradual' rate cuts, says 'should not rush'
Fed's Logan calls for 'gradual' rate cuts, says 'should not rush'
Oct 10, 2024
(Reuters) - Dallas Federal Reserve Bank President Lorie Logan on Wednesday said she supported last month's outsized interest-rate cut but wants smaller reductions ahead, given still real upside risks to inflation and meaningful uncertainties over the economic outlook. Following last month's half-percentage-point cut in the fed funds rate, a more gradual path back to a normal policy stance will likely...
CBO estimates $1.8 trillion US deficit for fiscal 2024
CBO estimates $1.8 trillion US deficit for fiscal 2024
Oct 10, 2024
WASHINGTON, Oct 8 (Reuters) - The Congressional Budget Office estimated on Tuesday a U.S. federal deficit of $1.834 trillion for fiscal 2024, the highest in the post-COVID era, as debt interest costs jumped sharply and outlays rose for Social Security, Medicare and health insurance tax credits. The estimate, which precedes the U.S. Treasury Department's year-end budget report later this month,...
US 30-year mortgage rate jumps to 6.36%, biggest weekly gain in 15 months
US 30-year mortgage rate jumps to 6.36%, biggest weekly gain in 15 months
Oct 10, 2024
(Reuters) - The interest rate for the most popular U.S. home loan rose to 6.36% last week, marking the biggest weekly increase in more than a year after better-than-expected economic data caused financial markets to scale back bets on further Federal Reserve interest-rate cuts. The average contract rate on a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage rose 22 basis points in the week...
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved