ORLANDO, Florida, May 7 (Reuters) - Amid all the
uncertainty surrounding U.S. growth, Federal Reserve policy, and
the attractiveness of the dollar, the U.S. bond market is
remarkably tranquil, calling into question long-held fears about
the massive 'basis trade'.
While Treasuries experienced a brief bout of volatility
following the Trump administration's 'Liberation Day' tariffs
last month, including a spike in long-term yields and
dislocation in 30-year swap spreads, the $29 trillion market has
withstood everything thrown at it.
Indeed, positioning in Treasury futures has quietly risen in
recent weeks and is now close to a record aggregate peak across
two-, five- and 10-year contracts. In the five-year space, both
'long' and 'short' positions have never been higher.
The Treasury futures market is where hedge funds operate the
basis trade, an arbitrage that profits from making highly
levered bets on tiny differences between the price of cash bonds
and futures.
Global financial authorities have repeatedly warned that, if
suddenly unwound, these positions - levered up to 100 times -
could pose a threat to financial stability, as sharp price
swings could trigger a devastating dash for cash and scramble to
cover.
But that hasn't happened yet, despite all the market
volatility over the past month.
Instead asset managers and leveraged funds are steadily
building their 'long' and 'short' positions, respectively.
Aggregate holdings across two-, five- and 10-year futures
contracts are all comfortably above $1 trillion in notional
terms. Speculators seem happy to continue peeling off the pips
in the basis trade, and asset managers are happy to lock in
yields between 3.80% and 4.20%.
"It's maybe a little surprising how fast these positions are
being rebuilt, but it shows a generally salient view leveraged
investors have in the functioning of the repo and Treasury
markets," says Steven Zeng at Deutsche Bank.
SOLID FOUNDATIONS
Treasury market depth may be a bit thinner than normal but
it's nowhere near crisis levels, and there's no sign of the
funding stress of late 2018, or September 2019 when the Fed was
forced to inject liquidity into the market.
The 'MOVE' index of implied Treasury market volatility has
come down almost as quickly as it spiked in early April and is
now below its average of the last three years.
Overnight repo rates, which hedge funds can use to fund the
basis trades, spiked at the height of the tariff turmoil a month
ago, but that was an insignificant blip compared to the surges
in 2018 and 2019. Repo rates are now in the middle of the Fed's
4.25-4.50% policy target range.
Meanwhile, New York Fed data shows that the volumes of
overnight cash borrowed at the Secured Overnight Financing Rate
(SOFR) hit a record $2.8 trillion at the end of April. That
suggests liquidity is ample, demand is strong and investors have
confidence in this source of funding. These all appear to be
signs of a well-functioning market.
True, there is some sign of elevated anxiety in the Treasury
market. The 'term premium' - the risk premium investors demand
for buying longer-dated bonds rather than rolling over
short-dated loans - has risen to the highest in a decade.
And there is always the risk that a sharp spike in borrowing
costs - perhaps driven by another policy surprise or twist in
the ongoing trade war - could put the basis trade in peril. But
then what?
If things did start to unravel, the Federal Reserve or
Treasury Department would almost certainly come in with a
backstop to preserve financial stability and maintain bond
market functioning.
So despite the fearmongering, the $1 trillion 'basis trade'
remains the dog that has barely barked, let alone bitten.
Perhaps the deepest and most liquid market in the world is
simply more robust than some Cassandras would have you believe.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters)
(By Jamie McGeever
)