ORLANDO, Florida, Oct 6 (Reuters) - The U.S. government
shutdown is delaying key economic data releases, thickening the
fog of uncertainty for policymakers and businesses, but they
needn't worry. They still have access to one of the best
economic indicators: the stock market.
That may sound flippant, but the connection between U.S.
equity prices, consumer spending and economic growth is
strengthening. By some measures, it has never been stronger.
This helps explain one of economists' big 'misses' this
year: stubbornly resilient U.S. consumption. They seem to have
underestimated the powerful, positive feedback loop of
gravity-defying strength on Wall Street and consumer spending,
the so-called wealth effect.
U.S. households have rarely been richer and have never had
so much of their wealth in the stock market. The epic rally in
equities is therefore making a lot of Americans feel a lot
richer, increasing their propensity to spend. This is
particularly true of the wealthiest households, who account for
an outsized share of consumer spending.
The Federal Reserve's national financial account figures for
the second quarter, the latest available, are revealing on this
measure.
Total household net wealth rose by $7.09 trillion, the
third-largest increase on record, with rising equity prices
contributing an eye-popping $5.51 trillion to gains in household
wealth during the period. This reflects the fact that equities'
share of total household assets has risen to a record 31%, or
more than 45% of households' financial assets, another record.
Considering the sheer size of these figures, it's reasonable
to assume that the 'wealth effect' is one major reason why
Americans are continuing to spend.
BIG SPENDERS
Economists are questioning the resilience of this
consumption, however, as the U.S. labor market is showing signs
of creaking, if not buckling. Job growth has essentially ground
to a halt, and while this may partly be a consequence of reduced
immigration, it still isn't something typically associated with
robust household consumption.
Yet economists at TD Securities - who share concerns about
the weakening U.S. job market - still expect consumer spending
to accelerate in the third quarter to a 3.2% annualized rate,
from 2.5% in the second, raising their GDP growth forecast to
2.8% from 2.2%.
What explains this seeming incongruity?
Namely, the rich, who largely thanks to roaring equity
markets, keep getting richer.
Consumption may always be driven by the wealthy, but that's
especially true today. The richest 10% of Americans account for
around half of all consumer spending, which itself represents
around 70% of all U.S. economic activity.
And the richest of all - the top 0.1% of households - saw
their share of total household wealth rise to a record 13.9% in
the second quarter, a period in which the S&P 500 rose 10.5% and
the tech-dominated Nasdaq rose 17.5%.
These indices rose another 8% and 11%, respectively, in the
third quarter, indicating that households felt even richer than
they did in the second. Rich enough to keep on spending
liberally?
The answer is likely "yes." Economists at Goldman Sachs
reckon that positive wealth effects may be strong enough to
support consumer spending growth over the next year, especially
after it gets a boost from the Trump administration's tax cuts.
Goldman estimates quarterly annualized consumption growth
was around 0.3 percentage points in the July-September period
and will be around 0.2 percentage points over the next year.
That's assuming equity prices rise in line with nominal GDP
growth. If equity markets keep booming, consumption could
eclipse economists' expectations yet again.
REASONS TO BE CAUTIOUS
Of course, the 'wealth effect' is no guarantee of an
uninterrupted consumption boom. While actual spending remains
fairly healthy, consumer confidence is low, near the lowest on
record, in fact, according to the University of Michigan's
sentiment index. But that's the confidence of the average
consumer, not the richest who keep seeing their stock portfolios
appreciate.
And as TS Lombard's Dario Perkins points out, the savings
rate should fall when net worth rises, as consumers take out
cash and spend. That's not happening now - the savings rate is
low at around 5%, but it has barely moved for the last few
years.
Finally, stocks could stop defying gravity. Claims that
we're reaching a market top have been growing lately. But as
long as optimism about artificial intelligence remains elevated
and U.S. tech companies continue recording strong earnings, that
long-awaited correction will stay just out of reach.
That's good news for U.S. equity holders, and, on balance,
the economy as a whole.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters)