ORLANDO, Florida, Nov 19 (Reuters) - Conditions are ripe
for a strong rally in the 'safe haven' Japanese yen, with a
global stock market selloff sparking volatility across asset
classes. But the Japanese currency is falling fast, calling into
question its long-perceived role as a preferred hiding spot for
spooked investors.
The yen this week has tumbled to a 10-month low against the
dollar and the weakest level ever against the euro. It has been,
by far, the worst-performing G10 currency in recent months,
raising the prospect of Japanese authorities intervening to lend
it some support.
Domestic issues are the key factor here. Japan's new Prime
Minister Sanae Takaichi appears to be taking notes from the
Donald Trump playbook: go large on fiscal stimulus and lean on
the central bank to keep interest rates as low as possible, even
if inflation is elevated.
Unsurprisingly, investors are in no rush to pile into the
yen despite the global market jitters.
The yen's status as a major safe-haven currency, which it
shares with the U.S. dollar and Swiss franc, is rooted in the
large current account surpluses and ultra-low or zero interest
rates that Japan ran for decades.
These conditions gave rise to the yen carry trade. Japanese
investors recycled the surpluses into higher-yielding assets
overseas, making Japan the world's largest creditor nation for
many years. At the end of June, Japan held a net $3.62 trillion
in overseas stocks and bonds, according to the International
Monetary Fund.
In previous bouts of global market turbulence, repatriation
of even a slender slice of that mountain of assets could deliver
a quick, outsized boost to the yen.
But that's not happening now. Perhaps the tremors roiling
global markets aren't strong enough yet. Or, to cite that
dreaded phrase, perhaps this time is different.
CARRY THAT WEIGHT
To put it bluntly, Japan's domestic policy stance is not
yen-friendly at all.
A ruling-party panel of lawmakers close to Takaichi has
proposed a supplementary budget exceeding 25 trillion yen ($161
billion) to fund Takaichi's planned stimulus package. That's
more than estimates floated recently and much larger than last
year's $92 billion plan.
Meanwhile, Takaichi has also indicated she would prefer the
Bank of Japan not to raise interest rates. Markets have reacted
accordingly. Japanese government bonds have tumbled, sending
yields to historic highs, and the swaps market indicates that
the probability of BOJ rate hikes in the coming months has
fallen sharply.
One might argue similar policy and political pressures are
prevalent in the United States, and should therefore be pushing
the dollar lower. That's fair, but these dynamics have been at
play for months, so are surely priced in by now. Takaichi has
been in power barely a month.
"The 'safe haven' status is challenging when so many of the
negative shocks are Japan-based," says Steven Englander, head of
G10 FX strategy at Standard Chartered. "The yen is super-low
yielding in real and nominal terms. It takes a lot to overcome
that."
FROM BOTH SIDES
The BOJ's tightening process was already slow and gradual.
It last raised its policy rate in January, doubling it to 0.5%,
meaning Japan's real interest rates adjusted for inflation are
still deeply negative. This is fertile ground for carry trades.
Exchange rates are obviously two-sided, so it is a cruel
twist for yen bulls that the BOJ could be slowing its tightening
process just as the Federal Reserve seems to be doing the same
with its easing plans. As the yen has been the worst-performing
G10 currency in the second half of the year, the dollar has been
the biggest gainer.
A deeper rout in U.S. and global markets in the coming weeks
could unwind some of these yen carry trades and restore the
Japanese currency's safe-haven allure.
On the other hand, with Japan's domestic policy mix being
what it is, maybe that will be more of a challenge this time
around.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters)
Enjoying this column? Check out Reuters Open Interest (ROI),
your essential source for global financial commentary. ROI
delivers thought-provoking, data-driven analysis of everything
from swap rates to soybeans. Markets are moving faster than
ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn and X.