ORLANDO, Florida, Oct 21 (Reuters) -
U.S. stocks were mixed on Tuesday, with the global momentum
that had lifted Japanese and several other indices to new highs
fizzling out, as investors digested a sharp fall in gold prices
and the U.S. government shutdown entering its third week.
More on that below. In my column today, I look at the Trump
administration's purchases of Argentine pesos, which appears to
be the U.S. government's first ever unilateral and direct FX
market intervention to support an emerging market currency. Why
Argentina, and will it work?
If you have more time to read, here are a few articles I
recommend to help you make sense of what happened in markets
today.
1. FOMO meets FOWO in edgy markets: Mike Dolan
2. EU gets a lousy 'Draghi report' card. But it
might not
matter: Klement
3. Japan's next finance minister could unsettle yen
bears
4. China's consumer subsidy scheme needs a rethink
5. Why is inflation so high in the UK?
Today's Key Market Moves
* STOCKS: New highs for Australia, Japan, South
Korea,
Taiwan, France, euro zone. Asia ex-Japan highest since February
2021. Wall Street mixed - S&P 500, Nasdaq essentially flat, Dow
+0.5%.
* SHARES/SECTORS: GM shares +15%, Warner Bros +11%,
Netflix slumps 7% in after hours trade following Q3 earnings.
U.S. industrials +0.9%, consumer discretionaries +1.3%,
utilities -1%.
* FX: Dollar rises for a third day, biggest gains vs
ZAR,
THB and KRW. Argentina's peso falls to a new low, Japanese yen
slides after new finance minister appointed.
* BONDS: U.S. Treasuries rise across the curve,
yields
down 3 bps at the longer end.
* COMMODITIES/METALS: Gold falls as much as 6%,
silver
slumps 8%. Oil settles 0.5% higher, bouncing off Monday's
5-month low.
Today's Talking Points
* U.S.-China tensions
Buoyant stocks suggest investors are confident
U.S.-China trade tensions will ease, as both sides cool the
rhetoric, step away from the brink, and strike a mutually
face-saving deal that ensures trade between the world's two
largest economies keeps flowing.
That may reflect over-confidence, or complacency. The mood
at the IMF/World Bank meetings in Washington last week was far
less upbeat, with the recent escalation around rare earths and
100% tariffs marking a new and worrying phase. Markets are
priced for significant de-escalation, and if that doesn't
materialize, volatility could pick up.
* Gold finally at a tipping point?
Gold fell 6% on Tuesday, its largest decline since August
2020 and second biggest since 2013. After such a steep ascent -
its year-to-date gain last week was almost 70% - the inevitable
question now is: correction, or crash?
Some kind of correction was surely inevitable. Tuesday's
slide takes gold back to where it was only a week ago, which is
unlikely to fluster the gold bugs. But deeper reversals have to
start somewhere, and if the base for the surge is weakening -
central bank buying, debasement fears, asset reallocation,
"FOMO" buying - there could be more downside to come.
* Japan's new-look government
Japan has a new-look government, headed by hardline
conservative Sanae Takaichi, the country's first female prime
minister, and with Satsuki Katayama as the country's first
female finance minister.
Investors will be focused on how closely the government and
Bank of Japan work together, how much fiscal stimulus is coming
down the pike, and whether the BOJ sticks to its gradual policy
tightening path. The initial verdict, at least, seems clear -
looser policy, higher stocks and a weaker yen.
Trump sets head-scratching FX intervention precedence in
Argentina
The Trump administration has engaged in what appears to be
the U.S. government's first ever unilateral foreign exchange
intervention to support an emerging market currency - and the
country in question is Argentina, a poster child for economic
volatility.
The Treasury on Thursday October 9 sold an unspecified
amount of U.S. dollars for Argentine pesos, followed up with a
second round of peso-buying intervention on Wednesday October
15, and a third the following day. All three rounds are part of
the U.S. administration's broader package of measures to support
Argentina's beleaguered economy and battered financial markets.
The U.S. has a long history of offering emerging economies
financial support, most notably Mexico in the mid-1990s, but
almost always via credit lines, loans or currency swap lines. It
is the nature of Washington's financial support to Buenos Aires
that sets this episode apart.
Since the Bretton Woods era of fixed exchange rates ended
over 50 years ago, the Treasury has, to the best of our
knowledge, never officially waded into the global FX market to
unilaterally spend taxpayer dollars on foreign currency, least
of all one as volatile as Argentina's peso.
'UNUSUALLY RISKY'
What is behind this unprecedented move?
It certainly is not close economic ties between the U.S. and
Argentina. Total bilateral goods and services trade last year
amounted to only around $26 billion, just 0.35% of America's
global $7.3 trillion trade activity.
For comparison, U.S.-Brazil trade last year was five times
larger at around $128 billion.
Another suggestion is that the U.S. could be making a
long-term strategic move here as part of its rivalry with China.
Argentina is home to significant lithium and copper
deposits, as well as, potentially, rare earth minerals. If
supporting the peso and agreeing to set up a $20 billion swap
line helps dilute Beijing's influence in Buenos Aires and the
region more generally, then Washington may see it as a price
worth paying.
But even if competition with Beijing is a motivation here,
which the administration hasn't publicly confirmed, there are
clearly other factors at play.
Namely, President Donald Trump appears to be using the FX
markets to back a political ally, Javier Milei, the unorthodox,
populist and controversial President of Argentina.
Trump suggested as much last week, saying, "we're not going
to waste our time" on Argentina if Milei's party doesn't win the
October 26 midterm legislative elections. Treasury Secretary
Scott Bessent later clarified that U.S. financial support would
continue as long as Milei's government pursues "good policies",
regardless of the election outcome.
But even if the administration is intent on supporting what
it deems "good policies", direct purchases of pesos are
"unusually risky", says Brad Setser, senior fellow at the
Council on Foreign Relations.
"The operation seems to be about supporting ideological
friends and expanding the set of Latin leaders that support the
U.S., and not about helping a large troubled emerging economy
fix its very real problems - in this case, a shortfall of
reserves and an overvalued currency," Setser says.
PESO DEVALUATION - WHEN, NOT IF?
The belief that this is mostly a political decision rather
than an economic one is why many analysts say Washington's
peso-buying spree is doomed.
For one, Argentina's macroeconomic situation remains
precarious. The country has spent decades battling crippling
inflation as well as currency and debt crises. And it currently
owes the International Monetary Fund around $57 billion, having
defaulted a further two times since its record default in 2001.
Milei has implemented a series of aggressive spending cuts,
deregulation and privatization reforms since sweeping to power
in 2023, and inflation has fallen to 32% from over 200%. But the
country is now back in a currency crisis, and pressure to remove
the peso from its dollar shackles, currently a trading band, is
immense.
Letting the currency float would trigger inflation
initially, but it should also boost exports, widen the trade
surplus, and allow the central bank to accumulate foreign
currency reserves again.
Bessent says the peso is undervalued, but most market
participants think the opposite is true. Despite Washington's
intervention, the Argentine currency slid to a record low of
1,476 per dollar on Monday. It thus seems less a question of
'if' the peso's devaluation will come, but 'when'.
If the crawling band is indeed scrapped, U.S. Treasury
support could then be the peso's only anchor in the immediate
term. But it's unlikely to hold for long without other reforms.
While the U.S. has long used access to the dollar to pursue
foreign policy goals, this direct FX intervention represents a
new tactic that, given its likelihood to produce losses, has
many investors scratching their heads.
What could move markets tomorrow?
* Japan trade (September)
* Indonesia interest rate decision
* UK inflation (September)
* U.S. Treasury auctions $13 billion of 20-year bonds
* U.S. earnings, including Tesla, SAP, IBM, AT&T
Want to receive Trading Day in your inbox every weekday
morning? Sign up for my newsletter here.
Opinions expressed are those of the author. They do not
reflect the views of Reuters News, which, under the Trust
Principles, is committed to integrity, independence, and freedom
from bias.