financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
J&J wins trial over Florida woman who claimed its baby powder caused her cancer
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
J&J wins trial over Florida woman who claimed its baby powder caused her cancer
Apr 18, 2024 3:14 PM

NEW YORK, April 18 (Reuters) - A Florida jury on

Thursday concluded that Johnson & Johnson's ( JNJ ) baby powder

talc product did not cause the ovarian cancer of a Florida woman

who died in 2019.

The lawsuit was brought by family members of Patricia

Matthey, a Sarasota County resident who used Johnson's baby

powder daily from 1965 until August 2016, when she was diagnosed

with ovarian cancer, according to her family's lawsuit.

J&J's Worldwide Vice President of Litigation Erik Haas said

the company was vindicated by the jury's decision.

"Consistent with decades of scientific research, the jury

appropriately found that talc is safe, does not contain asbestos

and does not cause cancer, which is the same outcome the company

achieved in 16 of 17 ovarian cases tried to date," Haas said.

Leigh O'Dell, an attorney for the Matthey family, said she

respects the jury's decision, but will remain "undeterred" in

future cases against J&J.

"The science supports the association between genital talc

use and ovarian cancer, and we will continue to seek justice for

the victims of J&J's neglect and indifference," O'Dell said.

Before her death, Matthey testified that advertisements for

baby powder made her think that she was "dirty and smelly" and

that she "needed Johnson's baby powder to be a good clean

person," according to evidence presented by her family's

attorney Lance Oliver during the trial.

The Matthey family alleged that J&J knew for decades that

the talc it mined for use in baby powder could be contaminated

with carcinogenic asbestos fibers. J&J suppressed scientific

evidence linking talc products to increased cancer risk,

according to the complaint.

J&J argued that there was no "conspiracy" to suppress

research. Instead, the scientific evidence simply does not

support the Matthey family's claims that its talc products cause

cancer, according to J&J.

"This is fundamentally a case about science," J&J's attorney

Morty Dubin said during opening statements in the trial.

J&J faces more than 50,000 lawsuits over talc, most by women

with ovarian cancer, with a minority of the cases involving

people with mesothelioma. Asbestos exposure is a known cause of

mesothelioma.

J&J has attempted to reach a comprehensive settlement of the

talc litigation through bankruptcy, but courts have rejected its

two previous attempts.

Haas has said that the company is considering a third

bankruptcy filing, and is trying to build more support for a

bankruptcy settlement among the plaintiffs that have sued the

company.

Haas said on Thursday that J&J will "continue to defend the

meritless talc claims in the tort system," while those

negotiations continue.

J&J's bankruptcy strategy put the talc litigation on hold

from 2021 to 2023, but trials have resumed after the latest

bankruptcy case was dismissed.

Trials in the talc cases have had a mixed record, with major

plaintiff wins including a $2.1 billion judgment in 2021 awarded

to 22 women with ovarian cancer.

A New Jersey appeals court in October threw out a $223.7

million verdict against the company, finding the testimony of

the plaintiffs' expert witnesses unsound. The most recent case

to go to trial ended in a hung jury on March 5.

J&J has recently settled some cases involving plaintiffs

with mesothelioma, but the company has not provided details

about the dollar amounts involved or said how many people they

covered.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Update: Market Chatter: Google's Alternative to Cookies Deemed Inadequate in Draft Report
Update: Market Chatter: Google's Alternative to Cookies Deemed Inadequate in Draft Report
Apr 22, 2024
03:24 AM EDT, 04/22/2024 (MT Newswires) -- (Updates with a response from Google ( GOOG ) in the last paragraph.) Alphabet-owned (GOOG) Google's ( GOOG ) proposed replacement for cookies lacks adequate privacy protections, a UK regulator says, according to documents cited by The Wall Street Journal. The UK's Information Commissioner's Office says that Google's ( GOOG ) proposed Privacy...
Australian steelmaker shares soar after AUKUS submarine contract
Australian steelmaker shares soar after AUKUS submarine contract
Apr 22, 2024
SYDNEY, April 22 (Reuters) - Shares in little known Australian steelmaker Bisalloy have risen some 40% since December on the back of a series of defence deals signed as part of the AUKUS nuclear submarine deal between Australia, Britain and the United States. Defence contractors large and small are looking at the A$368 billion ($237 billion) plan to build Australia...
CNH picks Iveco Group's Marx as new chief executive
CNH picks Iveco Group's Marx as new chief executive
Apr 22, 2024
* Marx to take CNH position on July 1 * Olof Persson appointed as new Iveco ( IVCGF ) CEO * CNH postpones Investor Day scheduled on May 21 * Both companies controlled by Exor April 21 (Reuters) - The holding company of Italy's Agnelli family has overseen a shakeup at the top of two of its major industrial groups,...
Update: Maxeon Solar Sues SAC Solar Over Alleged Cell Technology Patent Infringement
Update: Maxeon Solar Sues SAC Solar Over Alleged Cell Technology Patent Infringement
Apr 22, 2024
03:29 AM EDT, 04/22/2024 (MT Newswires) -- (Updates with a response from REC Solar in the last paragraph.) Maxeon Solar Technologies ( MAXN ) said Friday it has initiated a patent infringement lawsuit against REC Solar Holdings in the Eastern District of Texas. The lawsuit concerns alleged infringements of Maxeon's Tunnel Oxide Passivated Contact solar cell technology, the company said....
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved