Aug 12 (Reuters) - SpaceX's challenge to the structure
of the National Labor Relations Board will remain in Texas
federal court for now, after a U.S. appeals court overturned a
decision that would have transferred the rocket maker's lawsuit
to California.
A 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel in a two-sentence
order on Friday vacated a July decision by U.S. District Judge
Rolando Olvera refusing to reconsider an earlier ruling
transferring the case from his Brownsville, Texas, court to Los
Angeles.
The appeals court issued its decision without prejudice,
however, citing a related appeal that is still pending. That
means the NLRB can again move to transfer the lawsuit to
California, where SpaceX is based and the company is facing an
administrative board case claiming it illegally fired engineers
critical of CEO Elon Musk.
The 5th Circuit is considering SpaceX's separate claims that
Olvera improperly failed to rule on the company's request to
pause the NLRB case pending the outcome of the lawsuit. The
court in May temporarily blocked the board case from proceeding
while it considers SpaceX's appeal.
An NLRB spokeswoman declined to comment. SpaceX did not
immediately respond to a request for comment.
The lawsuit filed in January was among the first in a
growing number of challenges to the NLRB's in-house enforcement
proceedings, in which administrative law judges and then the
five-member board appointed by the president hear unfair labor
practice claims brought by the board's general counsel, who acts
as a prosecutor.
SpaceX says that administrative judges and board members are
improperly insulated from at-will removal by the U.S. president
and that NLRB proceedings violate the separation of powers and
the company's right to a jury trial under the U.S. Constitution.
The board is facing similar claims in cases involving
Amazon.com, Starbucks, Trader Joe's, pipeline operator Energy
Transfer ( ET ), a Michigan hospital operator, a small Missouri bank,
and a film producer, among others.
SpaceX filed a second lawsuit in Texas federal court in
April stemming from a separate NLRB complaint accusing the
company of forcing laid-off workers to sign severance agreements
that include illegal provisions. U.S. District Judge Alan
Albright in Waco in July blocked the board case from moving
forward pending the outcome of the lawsuit.
The NLRB has said the claims about its structure lack merit
and that the companies bringing the challenges are attempting to
distract from their violations of federal labor law.
The 5th Circuit panel includes Circuit Judges Jerry Smith
and Andrew Oldham, who were appointed by Republican presidents,
and Circuit Judge Carl Stewart, an appointee of Democratic
former President Bill Clinton.
The case is SpaceX v. NLRB, 5th U.S. Circuit Court of
Appeals, No. 24-40315.
For SpaceX: Catherine Eschbach, Harry Johnson and Michael
Kenneally of Morgan Lewis & Bockius
For the NLRB: David Boehm
Read more:
SpaceX wins block on US labor board case over severance
agreements
SpaceX seeks new Texas venue for challenge to NLRB after 5th
Circuit ruling
SpaceX wins temporary block on NLRB case over fired
engineers
SpaceX loses bid to keep challenge to NLRB structure in
Texas court
NLRB defends 'zealous advocacy' of SpaceX case transfer
SpaceX faces hearing on engineers fired after criticizing
Elon Musk over sexism
US judge blocks NLRB case against energy firm challenging
agency's structure
US Supreme Court ruling curbing agency powers could hobble
labor board
NLRB's Abruzzo hits back at 'low-road' companies challenging
agency's structure
(Reporting by Daniel Wiessner in Albany, New York)